🚨🌰 OHIO STATE DOESN’T NEED ANOTHER JULIAN SAYIN — IT NEEDS CRAIG KRENZEL MAGIC! WHY THE FORGOTTEN FORMULA BEHIND THE BUCKEYES’ 2002 NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP COULD SAVE EVERYTHING IN 2026!
Twenty-four years ago, Craig Krenzel proved that a quarterback didn’t need 400 passing yards, Heisman Trophy headlines, or spectacular statistics to lead Ohio State to a national championship. He needed discipline, courage, a punishing defense, a dependable running game, and the ability to deliver when everything was on the line. Now, with Julian Sayin sidelined and Ohio State preparing for USC, Ryan Day may need to rediscover the philosophy that made the 2002 Buckeyes unforgettable.
October 30, 2026 | Ohio State Buckeyes Football

FORGET FINDING ANOTHER SUPERSTAR — OHIO STATE ALREADY KNOWS HOW TO WIN WITHOUT ONE
Somewhere in Ohio State’s football history lies a championship formula that has become increasingly relevant as the Buckeyes prepare for their most uncertain stretch of the 2026 season.
It doesn’t begin with a quarterback throwing for 400 yards.
It doesn’t demand five touchdown passes, spectacular individual statistics, or a weekly performance that dominates the national conversation.
It begins with Craig Krenzel.
In 2002, Krenzel became the leader of an Ohio State team that repeatedly survived enormous pressure, won games that appeared almost impossible to win, and ultimately completed a perfect 14–0 national championship season.
The Buckeyes didn’t achieve that remarkable record because their quarterback overwhelmed every opponent with extraordinary passing numbers. They succeeded because Krenzel understood his responsibilities within a complete football team.
He protected possession, trusted his defense, accepted the importance of the running game, and delivered crucial plays when the championship dream was hanging by a thread.
Now, twenty-four years later, Ohio State finds itself facing a different version of the same fundamental challenge.
Julian Sayin, the quarterback who provided tremendous production throughout the opening seven games, is sidelined with a throwing-arm injury.
Luke Fahey and Tavien St. Clair must prepare for the possibility of leading the nation’s second-ranked team into a difficult Halloween-night matchup against USC.
But perhaps the biggest mistake Ryan Day could make would be demanding that either young quarterback immediately become another Sayin.
Ohio State already possesses elite receiving talent, a powerful defensive foundation, and the collective ambition necessary to remain dangerous.
What it needs is a quarterback who understands that championships are not awarded for having the most impressive individual box score.
The Buckeyes need someone who knows when to take care of the football, when to trust his teammates, and when to make the throw that changes everything.
That is the real Craig Krenzel formula.
And it is far more complicated than simply playing conservative football.
CRAIG KRENZEL WAS THE QUARTERBACK WHO MADE WINNING MORE IMPORTANT THAN STATISTICS
Krenzel’s 2002 numbers would look remarkably modest compared with the production expected from elite quarterbacks in modern college football.
Across fourteen games, he completed 148 of 249 passes for 2,110 yards, twelve touchdowns, and seven interceptions.
His completion percentage was 59.4 percent.
He averaged approximately 151 passing yards per contest, a total that would hardly dominate today’s quarterback discussions.
But those statistics tell only part of the story.
Krenzel also contributed through rushing and situational decision-making, helping Ohio State navigate games where one possession could determine whether the undefeated season survived.
His ability to remain composed became particularly valuable when the Buckeyes needed something beyond ordinary offensive execution.
Ohio State’s official historical records identify him as a central figure in the program’s championship success, including his selection as the offensive most valuable player of the national championship Fiesta Bowl.
The university also recognizes his 24–3 career record as a starting quarterback, a remarkable achievement reflecting how consistently his teams found ways to win.
Ohio State+1
That record captures something passing statistics cannot fully explain.
Krenzel wasn’t simply avoiding mistakes and hoping someone else would save him.
He was accepting the responsibilities necessary to give Ohio State its strongest chance of winning.
Sometimes that meant handing the football to Maurice Clarett.
Sometimes it meant maintaining possession and allowing the defense to control field position.
And sometimes it meant making an extraordinary throw when the entire season depended on his execution.
That balance explains why his legacy still matters.
Krenzel showed that leadership is not measured exclusively through spectacular production.
It is measured through the decisions that help a team succeed.
THE 2002 BUCKEYES DIDN’T DOMINATE EVERYONE — THEY SURVIVED EVERYONE
Ohio State’s perfect 2002 season is remembered as one of the program’s greatest accomplishments.
But the journey was anything but comfortable.
The Buckeyes repeatedly faced opponents capable of pushing them toward defeat, creating a season defined by narrow margins and extraordinary late-game execution.
Against Cincinnati, Ohio State survived 23–19.
Against Wisconsin, it escaped with a 19–14 victory.
Against Penn State, the Buckeyes prevailed 13–7.
Then came Purdue, where the offense struggled for most of the afternoon before producing one of the most famous plays in school history.
Ohio State won that game 10–6.
The following week brought another enormous challenge against Illinois, where the Buckeyes needed overtime to secure a 23–16 victory.
Then came Michigan.
With the national championship opportunity hanging in the balance, Ohio State defeated its fiercest rival 14–9.
The defining characteristic of those victories wasn’t overwhelming offensive production.
It was the team’s ability to keep competing until the final opportunity disappeared.
Krenzel understood that every possession mattered, particularly when the defense had created an opportunity to finish a close game.
His teammates understood the same responsibility.
The running backs competed for difficult yardage.
The defense limited scoring opportunities.
Special teams contributed to field position.
And the offense delivered enough to secure victory.
The Buckeyes ultimately entered their national championship showdown undefeated, but they had earned that record through repeated tests of patience, discipline, and collective determination.
For the 2026 team, that history offers a powerful reminder.
Ohio State does not need to defeat USC by thirty points to prove it remains a contender.
It needs to execute well enough to win.
And it needs to remember that difficult victories still count.
THE HOLY BUCKEYE PLAY WAS THE PUREST EXAMPLE OF KRENZEL MAGIC
There is one moment that captures Craig Krenzel’s championship identity better than any collection of statistics.
November 9, 2002.
Ohio State was trailing Purdue 6–3 late in the fourth quarter, facing the possibility that its undefeated national championship dream might disappear in West Lafayette.
The Buckeyes had struggled offensively, and the clock was becoming an increasingly dangerous opponent.
Then came fourth down.
Instead of surrendering to the circumstances, Krenzel delivered a 37-yard touchdown pass to Michael Jenkins.
The play became known as “Holy Buckeye.”
Ohio State won 10–6, preserving the perfect season and creating one of the most enduring moments in program history.
That single pass became legendary because of its timing.
Krenzel did not need four hundred passing yards to become the central figure in the story.
He needed to make one courageous, accurate decision when Ohio State could no longer afford another mistake.
There was nothing passive about that throw.
There was nothing timid about trusting Jenkins in such a demanding situation.
Krenzel accepted the risk because the moment required it.
And that is the distinction Ohio State must understand in 2026.
Playing smart football does not mean refusing to attack.
It means recognizing which opportunities deserve aggression and which situations require patience.
Fahey or St. Clair might spend an entire half managing possession, completing short passes, and allowing the defense to control the game.
Then USC could force a decisive third or fourth down.
Suddenly, the quarterback would need to deliver.
That is when Krenzel magic becomes relevant.
Not because history guarantees another miracle, but because the philosophy prepares a player to remain composed when the most important moment arrives.
THE DEFENSE WAS THE REAL SECRET BEHIND THE 2002 CHAMPIONSHIP
It would be impossible to understand Ohio State’s 2002 title without recognizing the extraordinary defense that supported Krenzel throughout the season.
Jim Tressel’s Buckeyes were built around physicality, discipline, and an ability to make opposing offenses uncomfortable.
Defensive stars such as Will Smith, Darrion Scott, Mike Doss, Matt Wilhelm, and Chris Gamble contributed to a unit that consistently kept opponents within reach.
Ohio State allowed approximately thirteen points per game, giving the offense enormous flexibility during difficult contests.
Krenzel didn’t have to score forty points simply to keep the Buckeyes competitive.
He knew the defense could limit opponents, protect narrow leads, and create opportunities for the offense to finish games.
That understanding shaped his approach.
There was less pressure to attempt reckless throws when a punt could preserve favorable field position and allow the defense to continue competing.
There was also greater freedom to trust the running game during situations where maintaining possession mattered more than generating explosive statistics.
The arrangement worked because both units respected their responsibilities.
The defense did not expect the offense to produce touchdowns on every drive.
The offense did not treat defensive excellence as permission to abandon discipline.
Together, they created an identity that became increasingly difficult to defeat.
That is the foundation of the 2002 championship formula.
Krenzel wasn’t an isolated hero rescuing an inadequate team.
He was the quarterback of an extraordinary collective effort.
And Ohio State’s 2026 roster may possess enough defensive talent to build something similar.
THE 2026 DEFENSE IS THE REASON THIS COMPARISON MAKES SENSE
Ohio State enters the USC matchup with a defensive foundation strong enough to support legitimate championship ambitions.
The Buckeyes are 6–1 overall and 4–0 in Big Ten competition, carrying the nation’s No. 2 ranking into Saturday’s showdown.
Their defense has become a defining strength, offering the kind of stability that can help an offense adjust to unexpected changes at quarterback.
The performance against Indiana demonstrated that quality.
Ohio State secured a 19–15 victory even after Sayin suffered his injury, relying on defensive execution during a difficult finish.
The win showed that the Buckeyes can survive when their offense is unable to overwhelm an opponent.
That is exactly the kind of situation in which the 2002 philosophy becomes relevant.
A championship-caliber defense can reduce the scoring burden placed on an inexperienced quarterback.
It can create favorable field position and help compensate when the offense needs time to establish rhythm.
But the defense still needs support.
Repeated turnovers would make its responsibilities more difficult.
Short offensive possessions could create fatigue.
And unnecessary penalties might give USC opportunities it would otherwise struggle to produce.
The Krenzel formula therefore demands discipline from the quarterback rather than asking him to perform miracles.
If Fahey or St. Clair protects possession and sustains enough drives, Ohio State can allow its defense to influence the outcome.
That approach won’t eliminate the need for offensive production.
USC possesses talented players and a passing attack capable of challenging strong defenses.
But it could give the Buckeyes a reliable foundation while their new quarterback develops confidence.
A strong defense does not guarantee a championship.
It does, however, make the path more realistic when the starting quarterback changes.
MAURICE CLARETT WAS JUST AS IMPORTANT AS CRAIG KRENZEL
One of the greatest mistakes in remembering the 2002 championship is concentrating exclusively on Krenzel while overlooking the offensive foundation that supported him.
Maurice Clarett was extraordinary.
The freshman running back rushed for 1,237 yards and sixteen touchdowns, establishing himself as one of the most important contributors to Ohio State’s unbeaten season.
His physical running allowed the Buckeyes to control possessions and avoid placing every responsibility on their quarterback.
When Clarett produced consistent gains, opposing defenses had to account for the rushing attack instead of concentrating exclusively on Krenzel.
That created passing opportunities and helped Ohio State maintain offensive balance.
Clarett’s contribution became particularly valuable during close contests, where controlling field position and maintaining possession could change the outcome.
He also demonstrated that a quarterback’s success is often connected to the quality of the players surrounding him.
Krenzel’s leadership mattered enormously.
But so did Clarett’s ability to create difficult yards when opponents expected Ohio State to run.
That lesson should be central to Ryan Day’s planning for USC.
The 2026 Buckeyes cannot simply announce that they will use the Krenzel formula while expecting Fahey or St. Clair to perform every important offensive responsibility.
The running backs need to provide real support.
The offensive line needs to establish physical control.
The receiving corps must execute consistently.
Only then can a young quarterback concentrate on making smart decisions instead of trying to rescue every possession.
The 2002 formula was collective football at its most effective.
It remains relevant precisely because it refuses to make the quarterback responsible for everything.
THE 2026 RUNNING GAME MUST BECOME MORE THAN A SECONDARY OPTION
Ohio State’s current running backs have an opportunity to become essential to the team’s revised offensive identity.
Bo Jackson and Ja’Kobi Jackson provide talent capable of generating meaningful gains, but the Buckeyes must establish greater consistency on the ground.
A strong rushing attack would create manageable passing situations for whichever quarterback receives the starting assignment.
A productive first-down run might allow Ohio State to choose from several options on second down.
A successful rushing sequence could force USC to commit additional defenders near the line of scrimmage.
That adjustment might create opportunities for Jeremiah Smith and the other receivers.
The relationship between the running game and passing attack is especially important when the quarterback lacks extensive starting experience.
Fahey or St. Clair should not be asked to repeatedly convert difficult third downs after unsuccessful early rushing plays.
That would allow USC to concentrate on generating pressure and disguising coverage.
Instead, Ohio State must create situations where the quarterback can execute manageable concepts without needing to rescue the offense through spectacular individual plays.
The running backs also need to contribute through pass protection.
A young quarterback who trusts his protection is more likely to remain composed while recognizing defensive adjustments.
But productive rushing requires more than effort from the backs.
The offensive line must establish leverage, communicate assignments, and avoid penalties that undermine promising possessions.
The entire offense must embrace the responsibility.
If Ohio State wants to borrow from 2002, it must begin by building a foundation that resembles Clarett’s influence rather than simply asking for Krenzel’s decision-making.
JEREMIAH SMITH MAKES THE MODERN VERSION EVEN MORE DANGEROUS
The most exciting difference between the 2002 team and the 2026 Buckeyes is the presence of Jeremiah Smith.
Ohio State has an extraordinary receiver capable of creating explosive opportunities that can change the character of a game.
Smith’s ability to challenge defensive coverage gives a young quarterback a potentially decisive advantage.
A perfectly designed offensive approach might produce several manageable completions, but Smith can also create something extraordinary when Ohio State needs a breakthrough.
That combination could allow Day to embrace Krenzel’s discipline while retaining the explosive possibilities associated with modern college football.
The goal should not be forcing the football toward Smith on every important play.
That would make the offense predictable and create opportunities for USC to generate turnovers.
Instead, Ohio State should use Smith strategically.
When he has a favorable matchup, the quarterback must be prepared to deliver.
When the defense assigns additional attention toward him, the offense should recognize opportunities elsewhere.
Smith’s presence can influence coverage even when he is not the intended target.
That ability benefits other receivers and could create space for the running game.
The important distinction is that Smith should become part of a balanced championship formula rather than the only reason the offense remains dangerous.
Krenzel’s greatest advantage was playing within a complete team.
Fahey or St. Clair will need the same opportunity.
But possessing a receiver of Smith’s caliber gives Ohio State an explosive option that could make the modern formula especially difficult to defend.
THE FIESTA BOWL REVEALED THE TRUTH ABOUT CHAMPIONSHIP QUARTERBACKS
The ultimate demonstration of Krenzel’s approach came against Miami in the national championship game.
The Hurricanes entered the Fiesta Bowl ranked No. 1 and riding a 34-game winning streak.
Their roster featured extraordinary talent, and many observers expected Miami’s offensive explosiveness to overwhelm Ohio State.
Instead, the Buckeyes fought through a remarkable contest that eventually required double overtime.
Krenzel did not dominate the passing statistics.
He completed seven of twenty-one attempts for 122 yards and threw two interceptions.
Those numbers hardly resemble the performance normally associated with a championship game’s offensive most valuable player.
Yet Krenzel also contributed 81 rushing yards and two rushing touchdowns, becoming an essential part of Ohio State’s ability to compete.
His fourth-down completion to Michael Jenkins during the first overtime preserved a crucial opportunity.
The Buckeyes eventually won 31–24, completing their undefeated season and securing the national championship.
Ohio State’s official historical account identifies Krenzel’s performance as central to the victory, recognizing him as the game’s offensive MVP.
Ohio State
That outcome demonstrates why quarterback evaluation cannot depend exclusively on passing yardage.
Krenzel made mistakes, but he also contributed enough decisive plays to help his team prevail against an extraordinary opponent.
The defense and surrounding roster provided the support necessary to overcome those imperfections.
That is the important comparison for 2026.
Fahey or St. Clair might throw for fewer than 200 yards in a difficult game and still contribute to victory.
But the quarterback must remain capable of delivering when Ohio State needs him.
The Krenzel formula is not about eliminating mistakes completely.
It is about keeping mistakes from destroying the team’s opportunity to win.
LUKE FAHEY DOESN’T NEED TO BECOME SAYIN TO SUCCEED
Luke Fahey has spent the season preparing as Ohio State’s primary backup quarterback.
The freshman earned that position during preseason competition and entered the Indiana game after Sayin suffered his injury.
Those experiences make him a credible candidate to lead the offense against USC.
But the danger would be expecting Fahey to reproduce everything Sayin accomplished through the opening seven games.
Sayin’s experience allowed Ohio State to operate with an extensive passing system and make adjustments that depended on his familiarity with defensive coverage.
Fahey is still developing those responsibilities.
That does not mean he cannot succeed.
It means the coaching staff must create a plan that emphasizes what he can execute confidently.
The Krenzel philosophy provides a useful framework.
Fahey should prioritize correct reads, accurate throws, and effective possession management.
He should recognize when a short completion provides more value than an unnecessary attempt downfield.
He should also understand that protecting the football doesn’t mean becoming afraid to make an important throw.
When Ohio State needs a decisive completion, he must trust his preparation and execute.
Fahey’s opportunity would not be defined by matching Sayin’s passing totals.
It would be defined by whether he can lead productive possessions and help his teammates remain competitive.
That is how an inexperienced quarterback can begin earning the trust of a championship roster.
TAVIEN ST. CLAIR CAN LEARN THE SAME LESSON
Tavien St. Clair arrived at Ohio State with an extraordinary recruiting reputation.
The former five-star prospect possesses the physical talent associated with a quarterback capable of making difficult throws.
But that reputation creates its own challenge.
Young players with celebrated arm strength may feel pressure to demonstrate their abilities through spectacular passing plays.
The Krenzel formula suggests a different approach.
St. Clair doesn’t need to prove that he can throw farther than everyone else.
He needs to demonstrate that he understands when a difficult throw is appropriate and when a simpler decision provides greater value.
A powerful arm can help Ohio State attack coverage.
But the advantage disappears if the quarterback repeatedly forces passes into dangerous situations.
St. Clair should therefore embrace the same principles that would help Fahey.
Protect possession.
Understand defensive coverage.
Use the running game.
Trust the defense.
Make important throws when opportunities emerge.
The coaching staff can evaluate whether St. Clair’s physical tools provide specific advantages against USC.
But his recruiting status should not become the deciding factor.
Ryan Day needs the quarterback who offers the strongest opportunity to execute consistently.
That requires preparation, composure, and the willingness to place team success ahead of individual production.
The Krenzel comparison gives both young quarterbacks a meaningful standard.
Not spectacular statistics.
Winning decisions.
RYAN DAY MUST RESIST THE TEMPTATION TO OVERCOMPLICATE EVERYTHING
The quarterback transition places significant responsibility on Ryan Day and offensive coordinator Arthur Smith.
Both coaches must decide how much of Ohio State’s original offensive approach remains suitable for players with limited meaningful game experience.
Trying to reproduce every element of Sayin’s offense could create unnecessary pressure.
A young quarterback may struggle if asked to manage extensive adjustments, identify complicated defensive disguises, and execute difficult passing concepts on every possession.
But simplifying the offense should not mean eliminating creativity.
The Buckeyes need enough variety to keep USC uncertain while providing the quarterback with manageable responsibilities.
That balance could involve more productive rushing, carefully designed passing reads, and opportunities for receivers to create yards after the catch.
The coaching staff should also identify situations where an aggressive throw becomes appropriate.
The 2002 lesson is not that Krenzel never took risks.
His celebrated touchdown against Purdue demonstrates the opposite.
He was willing to make a difficult play when his team needed it most.
Day must prepare Fahey and St. Clair for the same responsibility.
They should not feel obligated to create extraordinary moments on every possession.
But they must be ready when the game presents an opportunity that could determine the outcome.
That distinction separates disciplined offense from fearful offense.
And it may become the most important coaching challenge of Ohio State’s remaining season.
THE BIGGEST TEST ISN’T PASSING YARDS — IT’S THIRD DOWN
If Ohio State truly wants to embrace the Krenzel philosophy, third-down execution should become one of its most important priorities.
Championship quarterbacks often distinguish themselves through their ability to keep drives alive when opponents expect them to struggle.
A quarterback who converts third-and-five through an accurate short pass can provide enormous value without producing a spectacular highlight.
That conversion allows the offense to continue controlling possession.
It gives the defense additional rest.
And it prevents the opponent from immediately receiving another opportunity to score.
Those contributions become especially important in games decided by narrow margins.
The 2002 Buckeyes repeatedly found ways to sustain critical possessions when the championship dream appeared vulnerable.
Fahey or St. Clair may face similar moments against USC.
The Trojans will attempt to create pressure and force the inexperienced starter into difficult decisions.
Ohio State must respond through reliable protection and passing concepts suited to the quarterback’s abilities.
The running game also influences third-down success.
Productive early gains can create manageable situations, reducing the likelihood that USC will anticipate an obvious passing play.
The offensive line must therefore support the quarterback through both rushing and protection assignments.
Third down may not produce the same excitement as a sixty-yard touchdown.
But converting the right third down at the right time can become the difference between a frustrating defeat and an unforgettable victory.
TURNOVERS COULD DECIDE WHETHER THE FORMULA WORKS
Protecting the football remains one of the central principles behind Krenzel’s championship legacy.
But the lesson requires precision.
Krenzel did not finish the 2002 season without interceptions, and his national championship performance included two.
What made Ohio State effective was its ability to survive mistakes while creating enough successful possessions to win.
The 2026 Buckeyes must recognize that turnovers carry significant consequences, especially when an inexperienced quarterback faces a talented opponent.
An interception deep in Ohio State territory could provide USC with a short field.
A careless fumble might create scoring opportunities that undermine an otherwise excellent defensive performance.
Repeated mistakes could force Day to abandon the balanced approach intended to support his quarterback.
That would create even greater pressure, potentially leading to additional errors.
Ohio State must therefore establish clear expectations regarding decision-making.
The quarterback should recognize when a play has become unfavorable.
He should avoid forcing passes into heavy coverage merely to demonstrate confidence.
He must also protect the football when moving outside the pocket or absorbing contact.
But avoiding mistakes cannot become an excuse for refusing to compete aggressively.
The balance remains essential.
A championship quarterback makes responsible decisions while accepting that meaningful opportunities sometimes require calculated risk.
That is the standard Krenzel established.
It is the standard Ohio State needs now.
USC WILL NOT BE IMPRESSED BY NOSTALGIA
The historical comparison creates an inspiring narrative, but USC will approach the matchup with practical competitive objectives.
Lincoln Riley’s Trojans enter with a 6–2 record and an opportunity to defeat the nation’s No. 2 team at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum.
Ohio State’s quarterback uncertainty gives USC a potential tactical advantage.
The Trojans can attempt to pressure Fahey or St. Clair, disguise coverage, and force the new starter to make difficult decisions.
They will also recognize that Ohio State may place greater emphasis on rushing production.
That could encourage USC to challenge the line of scrimmage and make the Buckeyes prove that they can complete important passes.
The game will therefore test whether the Krenzel philosophy can be adapted effectively to the current roster.
Ohio State cannot win because supporters remember 2002 fondly.
It cannot win merely because its defense resembles the earlier championship team statistically.
And it cannot assume that Fahey or St. Clair will produce a memorable late-game moment simply because Krenzel once did.
The Buckeyes must execute against the opponent in front of them.
That means handling pressure, establishing enough offensive balance, and maintaining discipline throughout four quarters.
The 2002 comparison can provide a philosophy.
Preparation and performance must provide the result.
THE MODERN PLAYOFF MAKES THE CHALLENGE EVEN HARDER
Ohio State’s current championship path differs significantly from the one Krenzel navigated twenty-four years ago.
The 2002 Buckeyes competed under the Bowl Championship Series structure, where an undefeated regular season placed them into the national championship game.
The modern College Football Playoff requires contenders to survive a more extensive postseason format.
That can create additional demands on a quarterback, particularly when facing several opponents capable of challenging the offense through different defensive approaches.
A strategy effective against USC might not produce identical results against Oregon, Michigan, or a powerful postseason opponent.
Some defenses may limit rushing opportunities, forcing Ohio State to become more aggressive through the air.
Others might concentrate on Jeremiah Smith and challenge the quarterback to distribute the football elsewhere.
Day must prepare for those possibilities.
The Krenzel formula should therefore become a foundation rather than an unchanging playbook.
Ball security, disciplined decision-making, and defensive trust remain valuable against every opponent.
But the specific offensive strategy must evolve with each matchup.
The best championship teams combine a consistent identity with the flexibility necessary to respond to different challenges.
Ohio State needs that balance.
A replacement quarterback who can manage games effectively while continuing to develop his passing abilities could provide the Buckeyes with a sustainable approach.
But a player who only avoids mistakes may eventually struggle when stronger opponents demand more scoring production.
The modern version of Krenzel magic must include adaptability.
THE REAL REASON OHIO STATE FANS SHOULD BELIEVE
The Buckeyes have not lost the foundation that made them one of the country’s strongest teams.
They still possess a formidable defense.
They still have Jeremiah Smith and an impressive collection of offensive talent.
They still have running backs capable of contributing to a balanced attack.
And they still have a coaching staff with opportunities to adjust its approach before the most demanding stretch of the season.
The uncertainty surrounding Sayin’s replacement is genuine.
On October 29, reporting confirmed that Ryan Day had not publicly selected either Fahey or St. Clair to start against USC.
Both quarterbacks have received preparation time, and the coaching staff has indicated confidence in their ability to contribute.
FOX Sports+1
That uncertainty should not automatically be interpreted as a reason for surrender.
The 2002 championship demonstrates why football success depends on more than possessing the most statistically impressive quarterback.
Krenzel became a beloved Ohio State figure because he repeatedly helped his team win.
His leadership was measured through competitive results and the ability to deliver in critical moments.
Fahey and St. Clair do not need to imitate his personality or exact playing style.
They need to understand the responsibilities that made him effective.
That is the source of legitimate optimism.
Ohio State does not need a new superstar overnight.
It needs a quarterback prepared to execute within a team that already possesses extraordinary strengths.
THE FINAL VERDICT: THE MAGIC OF 2002 CAN RETURN — IF OHIO STATE REMEMBERS WHAT MADE IT SPECIAL
Craig Krenzel’s championship legacy is not built on the idea that quarterbacks should avoid taking responsibility.
It is built on the opposite principle.
The quarterback must accept responsibility for making the right decision, even when the most impressive statistical option is not the smartest football play.
During the 2002 season, Krenzel threw for 2,110 yards and twelve touchdowns.
Those numbers were not extraordinary compared with modern elite quarterback production.
Yet Ohio State completed a perfect 14–0 season, defeated several formidable opponents, and captured the national championship against Miami.
Krenzel was named the offensive MVP of the Fiesta Bowl despite completing only seven passes.
He contributed crucial rushing yards, delivered important throws, and remained composed when the championship depended on difficult execution.
His teammates provided an extraordinary foundation.
Maurice Clarett established the rushing attack.
The defense consistently limited opposing offenses.
Special teams helped create favorable field position.
And Jim Tressel built an identity around discipline, confidence, and winning close games.
The championship represented the success of an entire team.
That is the lesson Ryan Day should embrace in 2026.
Ohio State cannot simply replace Julian Sayin’s production with another inexperienced quarterback and expect the offense to continue functioning exactly as before.
Fahey and St. Clair possess different levels of experience and different individual abilities.
The coaching staff must identify which player provides the strongest immediate opportunity to win while building a game plan suited to his strengths.
The quarterback should not feel pressured to deliver a spectacular passing performance simply because Sayin previously produced impressive statistics.
Instead, his responsibilities should emphasize accuracy, ball security, situational awareness, and the confidence to make important plays when they are available.
The running game must improve enough to provide meaningful support.
The offensive line must protect the quarterback and establish opportunities for productive rushing.
Jeremiah Smith should remain a central offensive weapon, but his teammates must also contribute when opponents devote additional defensive attention toward him.
The defense must continue performing at an elite level.
And the coaching staff must ensure that conservative decision-making does not become predictable or passive offense.
The Buckeyes need a quarterback willing to compete aggressively when the situation demands it.
That is what made Krenzel special.
He understood that protecting possession mattered, but he also recognized the moments when the season required something extraordinary.
The famous touchdown against Purdue was not a demonstration of timid football.
It was the result of courage, execution, and the willingness to take a calculated risk when no safer alternative could preserve the championship dream.
Ohio State’s next quarterback may eventually face a similar opportunity.
It might arrive against USC.
It might come during a difficult November matchup.
Or it could emerge during the postseason if the Buckeyes maintain their championship position.
When that moment arrives, the quarterback must be prepared to deliver.
But he will not reach that moment alone.
The 2002 Buckeyes proved that quarterbacks become champions through the collective strength of their teams.
The 2026 roster possesses enough talent to embrace the same principle.
OHIO STATE DOESN’T NEED LUKE FAHEY OR TAVIEN ST. CLAIR TO THROW FOR 400 YARDS. IT NEEDS ONE OF THEM TO UNDERSTAND HOW TO WIN.
The verdict is clear: Craig Krenzel’s 2002 philosophy offers Ohio State a credible championship blueprint, but it requires stronger rushing execution, dependable defense, smart quarterback decisions, and the ability to deliver decisive plays under pressure.
The historical comparison cannot guarantee that the Buckeyes will win another national title.
But it provides a powerful reason to believe that Sayin’s absence does not automatically eliminate their opportunity.
CRAIG KRENZEL DIDN’T BECOME AN OHIO STATE LEGEND BECAUSE HE WAS THE MOST SPECTACULAR QUARTERBACK IN THE COUNTRY. HE BECAME A LEGEND BECAUSE HE FOUND A WAY TO WIN WHEN EVERYTHING WAS ON THE LINE.
TWENTY-FOUR YEARS LATER, THAT IS EXACTLY THE KIND OF QUARTERBACK OHIO STATE NEEDS.
PROTECT THE FOOTBALL. TRUST THE DEFENSE. RUN WITH PURPOSE. AND WHEN THE CHAMPIONSHIP DREAM COMES DOWN TO ONE FINAL PLAY, DON’T HESITATE.
THAT’S THE CRAIG KRENZEL WAY — AND THAT’S THE MAGIC THE BUCKEYES MUST REDISCOVER IN 2026. ❤️🌰🏈🔥