BIG TEN BOMBSHELL: OHIO STATE COULD BLOW UP COLLEGE FOOTBALL’S POWER STRUCTURE — BUT WOULD INDEPENDENCE BE A GENIUS MASTERSTROKE OR A BILLION-DOLLAR DISASTER – eirian

💣🌰 BIG TEN BOMBSHELL: OHIO STATE COULD BLOW UP COLLEGE FOOTBALL’S POWER STRUCTURE — BUT WOULD INDEPENDENCE BE A GENIUS MASTERSTROKE OR A BILLION-DOLLAR DISASTER?

Ohio State has one of the biggest brands in American sports, a massive national following, and the kind of television appeal that makes networks pay enormous money. Now a provocative independence debate is challenging everything the Big Ten represents. Could the Buckeyes control their own schedule, negotiate their own media future, and transform college football forever? Or would abandoning more than a century of tradition become the most expensive mistake in program history?

October 29, 2026 | Ohio State Buckeyes Football | Conference Realignment & College Football

THE QUESTION THAT COULD TERRIFY THE ENTIRE BIG TEN

College football has spent years tearing apart its traditional geography, rewriting financial relationships, and transforming conference membership into an increasingly complicated business decision. Now one extraordinary possibility has returned to the national conversation: what if Ohio State decided the Big Ten was no longer essential?

For generations, the Buckeyes have represented everything powerful about the conference. They bring enormous television interest, passionate supporters, championship expectations, and one of the most recognizable identities in American college athletics. Their departure would be more than another ordinary realignment announcement.

It would challenge the entire assumption that powerful football programs must remain attached to major conferences to maximize their value. Ohio State possesses something few universities can match: a brand capable of attracting national attention almost regardless of its opponent.

But is that recognition powerful enough to justify independence? Could the Buckeyes genuinely generate more revenue, create stronger schedules, and improve their championship opportunities by negotiating their own future rather than sharing power with seventeen conference partners?

The explosive sentiment behind such a decision could be summarized through one defiant declaration: “WE’VE BUILT ONE OF THE BIGGEST BRANDS IN DAMN COLLEGE FOOTBALL! IF THERE’S A BETTER PATH TO CHAMPIONSHIPS, WE HAVE TO BE WILLING TO LOOK AT IT. BUT WE’RE NEVER TURNING OUR BACKS ON WHAT MADE OHIO STATE GREAT!”

That imagined statement reflects the difficult balance surrounding the debate. Ohio State cannot ignore financial opportunities simply because tradition is important. But neither can it casually abandon historical relationships without understanding the competitive and institutional consequences of such a dramatic move.

The issue has attracted attention because prominent analysts have considered the possibility seriously enough to explore specific scheduling and television scenarios. That is not the same as an official proposal, but it shows how far the sport’s economic conversation has shifted.

An October 28 article examined a hypothetical model proposed by The Athletic’s Stewart Mandel, in which Ohio State and several other national powers could operate independently if future playoff structures reduced the importance of conventional conference championships.

HEAVY

 

The proposal is provocative precisely because Ohio State does not currently appear desperate to escape. The Big Ten provides enormous revenue, national exposure, competitive opportunities, and established relationships. Independence would mean abandoning substantial benefits in pursuit of an uncertain alternative.

That is what makes the discussion so compelling. The Buckeyes might be powerful enough to survive independently, but surviving and becoming better are entirely different achievements. The distinction could determine whether the idea becomes visionary strategy or an expensive historical miscalculation.

THE BIG TEN’S BIGGEST BRAND MIGHT NOT NEED THE BIG TEN’S PERMISSION

Ohio State’s football reputation was not built overnight. Decades of winning, championship expectations, memorable athletes, and nationally televised games have transformed the Buckeyes into an institution whose influence extends far beyond Columbus and the surrounding region.

The university’s supporters follow recruiting developments, coaching decisions, injuries, and rivalries with extraordinary intensity. That passionate engagement creates commercial value because broadcasters seek programs capable of attracting large, dependable audiences across multiple markets and competitive circumstances.

Supporters of independence would argue that Ohio State brings its audience wherever it goes. The Buckeyes do not suddenly become less recognizable because an opposing team wears a different conference patch or a television broadcast follows another scheduling arrangement.

They might also question why a program with such enormous drawing power should continue receiving revenue through a collective structure. If Ohio State contributes exceptional value, why shouldn’t it explore agreements that reflect its individual commercial importance?

However, this argument contains a major weakness. Collective television packages are valuable partly because they deliver predictable schedules, attractive matchups, and multiple prominent programs under coordinated agreements. Ohio State benefits from that organization as much as it contributes to it.

The Big Ten also provides opponents who strengthen the value of Buckeyes games. Michigan, Penn State, Oregon, USC, Wisconsin, and other conference members contribute their own supporters, histories, and competitive reputations to the broader television product.

An independent Ohio State would still need attractive opponents willing to schedule games. A nationally recognizable brand cannot manufacture compelling matchups without another institution agreeing to participate under workable financial and competitive terms.

The difference between having bargaining power and controlling every decision matters enormously. Ohio State could negotiate aggressively, but television networks, opposing universities, and postseason administrators would retain substantial influence over its available options.

That reality creates the central contradiction. Independence could increase Ohio State’s autonomy while simultaneously making the program more dependent on separate agreements with institutions that currently operate through established conference relationships.

The Buckeyes have enough prominence to explore the possibility. But turning brand power into a superior independent operating model would require far more than pointing toward television ratings and declaring the conference unnecessary.

THE TELEVISION EMPIRE THAT COULD MAKE OHIO STATE EVEN RICHER

Money sits at the center of the independence debate because college football’s television economy has become enormous. The Big Ten’s existing agreements with Fox, CBS, NBC, and associated platforms demonstrate just how valuable major conference football has become.

The conference announced its current major broadcasting arrangements in August 2022, with the agreements covering the period through the 2029-30 athletic year. Widely reported estimates placed their combined value above $7 billion, with broader industry calculations reaching approximately $8 billion.

Ohio State+1

 

Those numbers explain why walking away would be so controversial. Ohio State already participates in one of the richest media structures in college sports, receiving the benefits of collective negotiation without independently assembling every major broadcasting agreement.

But the same extraordinary figures encourage a more provocative question. If the conference can generate billions collectively, how much would networks offer for direct access to Ohio State’s football home games and nationally attractive scheduling inventory?

An independent Buckeyes package might interest traditional broadcasters, streaming platforms, and companies seeking premium live sports programming. Ohio State’s national profile could provide commercial appeal across several distribution models rather than one familiar conference structure.

Imagine a television agreement built around high-profile home games against Georgia, Texas, Notre Dame, Penn State, or Michigan. The potential audiences could attract intense interest from companies competing for valuable football rights.

Yet there is no verified independent television offer demonstrating that Ohio State would actually earn more money. Any serious evaluation must separate theoretical commercial potential from the amount broadcasters would commit under enforceable contracts.

The university would also need to account for existing obligations, lost conference distributions, broadcasting production arrangements, scheduling expenses, and the possibility that some attractive matchups become difficult to secure consistently.

A higher headline television figure would not automatically create greater financial value. Ohio State would need to compare reliable net revenues rather than assuming that direct control inevitably produces superior results.

That is the billion-dollar question at the heart of the controversy. Independence might create substantial commercial opportunities, but the evidence needed to prove it financially superior has not yet been established.

THE 2030 MEDIA WINDOW COULD CHANGE THE ENTIRE CALCULATION

The timing of the Big Ten’s existing media agreements creates an obvious reference point for anyone considering future structural changes. The current major contracts extend through the 2029-30 athletic year, making the next broadcasting cycle strategically important.

That does not mean Ohio State is planning a departure in 2030. There is no verified decision supporting such a claim, and the expiration of a media contract does not automatically eliminate every other institutional or contractual obligation.

However, negotiations surrounding future rights agreements could provide opportunities to reevaluate financial expectations. Networks may consider different distribution models, and conference members may examine whether existing structures continue delivering sufficient value.

Ohio State would enter those conversations with considerable leverage because its games contribute meaningful national visibility. But leverage does not automatically mean the university would prefer independence over an improved conference arrangement.

The Big Ten could also adapt. New revenue-sharing approaches, broadcasting terms, or competitive structures might make continued membership attractive to its most prominent football programs.

Conversely, future financial arrangements could create disagreements if some institutions believed their contributions were not adequately reflected in the distribution of commercial revenue.

Those possibilities remain speculative, but they explain why analysts continue examining long-term independence scenarios. College football’s commercial structure is evolving, and institutions must understand how different arrangements could affect their futures.

The decisive consideration would be evidence. Ohio State would need realistic media proposals, scheduling commitments, and clear projections before independence could become anything more than a provocative thought experiment.

Until those elements exist, discussing 2030 as an automatic departure date would be misleading. The period matters because of existing contracts, not because the university has announced an intention to leave.

NOTRE DAME PROVES INDEPENDENCE CAN WORK — BUT THE COMPARISON HAS LIMITS

Notre Dame is the most obvious comparison because the Fighting Irish have maintained a distinctive independent football identity while remaining nationally prominent. Their experience demonstrates that conference membership is not an absolute requirement for commercial visibility or competitive relevance.

The Irish also possess a longstanding television relationship with NBC. In November 2023, the network announced an extension covering Notre Dame home football games through the 2029 season, reinforcing a partnership that began in 1991.

NBC Sports

 

That agreement provides independence supporters with an attractive example. A nationally recognizable university can establish a direct broadcasting relationship and preserve a football identity separate from traditional conference membership.

But Notre Dame’s model reflects decades of institutional development. The Irish have cultivated scheduling relationships, independent traditions, and operational expectations that differ substantially from Ohio State’s historical circumstances.

Ohio State has been deeply connected to the Big Ten since joining the conference in 1912 and beginning league football competition in 1913. Independence would represent a fundamental structural transformation rather than the preservation of an existing identity.

Notre Dame also benefits from arrangements that help address scheduling challenges. An independent Ohio State would need to establish its own dependable partnerships rather than assuming that every nationally prominent opponent would suddenly become available.

The comparison becomes especially complicated when considering television economics. Notre Dame’s commercial agreements reflect its specific brand, schedule, and historical relationships; Ohio State cannot automatically expect identical terms or outcomes.

There is also the competitive question. The Irish have faced their own scheduling difficulties as major conference members increasingly operate within demanding league calendars, limiting available opportunities for attractive nonconference games.

Independence therefore provides freedom without removing practical constraints. Schools may control more of their scheduling strategy but still depend on willing opponents whose priorities and obligations differ from their own.

Notre Dame proves that the model can function. It does not prove that Ohio State would become richer, more competitive, or better positioned for championships simply by adopting the same general classification.

THE DREAM SCHEDULE THAT COULD TURN EVERY SATURDAY INTO A BLOCKBUSTER

One of the most exciting elements of the proposal involves Ohio State assembling an independent national schedule. Rather than accepting a fixed Big Ten conference slate, the Buckeyes could theoretically negotiate opponents based on competitive significance and commercial appeal.

Mandel’s hypothetical example included Bowling Green, Wisconsin, Nebraska, Kansas State, Virginia, Texas, Iowa State, Georgia, Pittsburgh, Penn State, Youngstown State, and Michigan. The slate was illustrative, not an announced Ohio State schedule.

HEAVY

 

That combination would preserve several familiar relationships while introducing high-profile matchups against programs outside the Big Ten. It would also create the possibility of making major interconference games a regular feature rather than an occasional event.

Imagine Ohio Stadium welcoming Georgia in September, Texas arriving during another season, and Notre Dame returning for a nationally televised showdown. Such games could become enormous attractions for supporters, broadcasters, recruits, and sponsors.

But the excitement comes with a serious competitive risk. A schedule loaded with prominent opponents could expose Ohio State to more difficult games than the program would encounter during certain conventional conference seasons.

Losses against elite competition could influence postseason rankings, especially if future selection procedures did not sufficiently reward ambitious scheduling. Independence would require balancing television attractiveness with realistic championship objectives.

The schedule would also need enough home games to sustain stadium revenue and local economic activity. Ohio State cannot simply maximize recognizable opponents without considering where those contests would take place.

Opposing institutions would possess their own priorities. Georgia, Texas, and other prominent programs might have limited nonconference availability, making repeated negotiations more complicated than independence supporters initially imagine.

A carefully constructed national slate could strengthen Ohio State’s brand and create extraordinary experiences for supporters. A poorly managed one could introduce financial uncertainty, excessive travel, and difficult competitive circumstances.

The schedule might become independence’s greatest selling point, but only if Ohio State secured dependable opponents and agreements that protected its long-term interests rather than relying on theoretical dream matchups.

THE MICHIGAN PROBLEM COULD DESTROY THE WHOLE IDEA

For many supporters, the independence debate eventually reaches one nonnegotiable subject: Michigan. The rivalry represents decades of emotion, institutional competition, and memories that have helped define Ohio State football.

Leaving the Big Ten would not automatically end The Game, but it could complicate the established framework supporting the annual matchup. Both universities would need to agree on future scheduling arrangements under their respective commitments.

If Michigan remained in the conference, it would still operate within a league schedule. Finding room for an annual independent Ohio State matchup could require careful coordination and long-term contractual agreements.

The commercial incentives would be enormous. Ohio State-Michigan is already one of college football’s most recognizable events, giving both institutions strong reasons to preserve it regardless of conference affiliation.

Yet television value alone cannot resolve every scheduling complication. Networks, conference administrators, athletic departments, and competitive calendars could all influence when and how the rivalry continued.

Independence supporters might argue that The Game could become even bigger as a standalone event, no longer carrying ordinary conference implications but maintaining enormous national importance.

Traditionalists would respond that those conference implications are part of what made the rivalry so powerful. Winning the Big Ten while defeating Michigan has long been intertwined with the Buckeyes’ championship identity.

Removing that framework might change the emotional stakes even if the annual game survived. Some supporters would welcome the transformation, while others would view it as an unnecessary sacrifice.

A serious independence proposal would therefore need to protect the rivalry through concrete agreements rather than vague promises that tradition would somehow take care of itself.

If Ohio State could not guarantee a dependable Michigan matchup, the political and emotional resistance among its own supporters could become one of the greatest obstacles to leaving.

WOULD THE BIG TEN STILL BE THE BIG TEN WITHOUT THE BUCKEYES?

Ohio State’s hypothetical departure would create questions extending far beyond Columbus. The Big Ten’s identity relies partly on the nationally recognized programs that contribute to its competitive reputation and commercial value.

Losing the Buckeyes would remove one of the conference’s most recognizable attractions, potentially affecting the value of future television negotiations and the availability of marquee football matchups.

But declaring that the entire conference would immediately collapse would be an exaggeration. Michigan, Penn State, Oregon, USC, Wisconsin, and other institutions would continue contributing significant athletic and commercial value.

The more serious danger would emerge if Ohio State’s departure encouraged additional prominent programs to reevaluate membership. A series of exits could fundamentally change the financial assumptions supporting the existing conference structure.

That possibility explains why the independence scenario attracts attention beyond one university. It raises questions about whether collective conference membership remains the preferred financial model for the largest football brands.

The Big Ten might respond by restructuring revenue arrangements, emphasizing remaining rivalries, or developing new ways to preserve the commercial value of its collective broadcasting package.

However, those outcomes would depend on circumstances that do not currently exist. There is no confirmed coordinated departure plan involving Ohio State and other prominent conference members.

For now, the conference continues operating as an eighteen-member organization with extensive broadcasting relationships and established competition schedules. Its existing strength should not be dismissed because analysts are exploring hypothetical alternatives.

The fascinating question is whether that strength could eventually become vulnerable if several powerful universities concluded that individual commercial arrangements offered greater benefits.

Ohio State’s potential departure would represent a historic challenge to the Big Ten, but the actual consequences would depend on who followed, how media contracts evolved, and whether the conference adapted.

THE PLAYOFF COULD BE THE FACTOR THAT DECIDES EVERYTHING

Money attracts headlines, but postseason access might become the most important consideration in any independence decision. Ohio State’s competitive ambition centers on pursuing national championships, making the playoff structure essential to its long-term planning.

Conference affiliation currently interacts with championship qualification through established scheduling and postseason arrangements. Future changes could alter how much value a program receives from competing for a league title.

Mandel’s hypothetical framework considers a substantially expanded playoff, including the possibility of a 24-team format. That idea should be treated as speculation rather than a guaranteed future postseason system.

Under certain expanded arrangements, powerful independent programs might possess clearer routes to qualification without needing conference championship opportunities. That could reduce one traditional advantage of league membership.

But other formats might provide automatic opportunities or preferential treatment to conference champions. Independence could become less attractive if Ohio State faced more complicated qualification requirements than similarly successful conference members.

Scheduling strength would also matter. A series of difficult national matchups might help demonstrate competitive quality, but additional losses could influence rankings and seeding under particular selection rules.

Financial distributions from the postseason would introduce another complication. Ohio State would need to understand whether independent status changed its ability to access revenue associated with playoff participation.

The Buckeyes cannot make a responsible long-term decision without knowing how future postseason systems would treat independent programs. Commercial opportunity means less if championship access becomes less reliable.

Independence supporters may view playoff expansion as a potential opening. Critics may see the uncertainty surrounding future formats as another reason to preserve established conference membership.

Ultimately, Ohio State would need a structure that protected both revenue and realistic championship opportunities. Neither objective can be evaluated separately when the program’s entire identity revolves around competing at the highest level.

RYAN DAY WOULD INHERIT A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT FOOTBALL WORLD

The hypothetical shift would also affect Ohio State’s coaching responsibilities. Ryan Day currently operates within an established conference framework that shapes scheduling, recruiting conversations, opponent preparation, and competitive expectations.

An independent future could introduce greater scheduling flexibility but require the coaching staff to prepare for a wider range of opponents selected through separate agreements.

That variety might benefit player development by exposing athletes to different defensive systems, regional recruiting markets, and nationally prominent programs throughout the regular season.

However, demanding travel arrangements and unpredictable schedules could create challenges for preparation, recovery, and academic responsibilities. Additional flexibility does not automatically mean a more manageable season.

Recruiting would become another important consideration. Ohio State could promote its independence as an opportunity to compete against major national brands while showcasing its individual identity.

But recruits might also ask how the program would secure playoff access, maintain important rivalries, and guarantee meaningful competitive opportunities without traditional conference membership.

Day would need convincing answers rather than promotional promises. Talented athletes and their families evaluate development, stability, facilities, academic support, and professional opportunities alongside attractive schedules.

A nationally televised independent program could offer considerable exposure, but Ohio State already possesses substantial visibility within the Big Ten. The additional recruiting benefit would need to justify any new disadvantages.

The coaching staff would also face pressure if the transition produced disappointing results. Supporters might question whether independence had undermined a program that was already competing successfully.

The strongest argument would therefore focus on improvements that could actually be demonstrated. Independence should enhance Ohio State’s competitive environment rather than simply create a more dramatic public identity.

THE FORGOTTEN ATHLETES WHO COULD PAY THE PRICE

Football revenue drives much of the realignment debate, but Ohio State operates a much broader athletic department. Basketball, wrestling, volleyball, soccer, swimming, and other programs depend on institutional relationships that extend well beyond Saturday football.

An independent football arrangement would not necessarily require every Ohio State sport to leave the Big Ten. But continuing membership in other sports would require workable agreements rather than assuming the conference would automatically accept the arrangement.

If the Big Ten declined such a proposal, Ohio State might face difficult decisions about where its other teams would compete and how their conference schedules could be organized.

Those decisions could influence travel, academic commitments, championship opportunities, and operating expenses. Student-athletes outside football should not become secondary considerations simply because football broadcasting provides enormous commercial value.

The university’s broader academic relationships would also deserve attention. Conference membership has supported institutional cooperation beyond athletic competitions, meaning a departure could have consequences that television projections do not fully capture.

A responsible independence proposal would therefore require comprehensive planning. Ohio State would need to protect the interests of its entire athletic department rather than evaluating the football program as a completely separate enterprise.

THE FINAL VERDICT: A HISTORIC MASTERSTROKE OR AN UNFORGIVABLE MISTAKE?

Ohio State possesses one of college football’s most powerful brands. That reality gives the Buckeyes a credible reason to understand what independence might offer in an environment increasingly shaped by television rights and postseason economics.

But possessing the ability to explore independence does not establish that leaving the Big Ten would improve the university’s future. The current conference provides enormous revenue, established opponents, historical rivalries, and significant institutional stability.

The strongest independence argument centers on financial autonomy and scheduling flexibility. If Ohio State could secure superior broadcasting agreements while preserving its championship opportunities, the idea would deserve serious consideration.

The strongest argument for remaining involves predictable revenue, existing partnerships, and the enormous value of more than a century of conference relationships. Those advantages should not be dismissed merely because independence sounds exciting.

Neither side can establish a definitive financial outcome without real offers, contractual analysis, scheduling commitments, and clear information about future playoff structures. Those critical elements remain unresolved.

The proposed independence model is therefore a legitimate subject for strategic debate rather than an established path Ohio State is preparing to follow. A provocative scenario should not be confused with an official institutional decision.

Buckeye Nation has every reason to consider the possibilities. A national schedule featuring powerhouse opponents and a direct television arrangement could create extraordinary football experiences.

But those potential rewards would have to justify the possibility of losing familiar rivalries, established conference income, and important institutional relationships that helped build Ohio State’s national identity.

The university does not need independence to prove that it belongs among college football’s elite. Its history, enormous following, and competitive reputation already establish that standing.

What matters is whether an alternative structure could provide demonstrably stronger opportunities for the players, supporters, and institution without undermining the traditions that make Ohio State distinctive.

That is the real strategic challenge. Financial ambition should not be mistaken for progress, but tradition should not become an excuse for refusing to examine legitimate opportunities.

The program’s future deserves a decision built on evidence rather than fear, nostalgia, or speculation. Until an alternative offers clear advantages, leaving remains an unproven proposition.

For now, the Buckeyes remain Big Ten members, with their immediate attention directed toward their October 31 matchup at USC and the championship objectives already in front of them.

The independence debate will continue because college football’s economic structure is changing. But no amount of commercial speculation replaces the competitive responsibilities Ohio State must fulfill today.

OHIO STATE HELPED BUILD THE BIG TEN INTO A NATIONAL POWERHOUSE. NOW THE BIGGEST QUESTION IS WHETHER THE BUCKEYES COULD EVER BECOME EVEN MORE POWERFUL WITHOUT THE CONFERENCE THAT HELPED DEFINE THEIR HISTORY.

The conclusion is clear: independence could become a serious strategic option under different financial and postseason conditions, but there is currently no demonstrated case that it would outperform Ohio State’s existing Big Ten membership.

BUCKEYE NATION — WOULD LEAVING THE BIG TEN BE THE BOLDEST, SMARTEST MOVE IN OHIO STATE HISTORY, OR THE MOST EXPENSIVE MISTAKE THE SCARLET AND GRAY COULD EVER MAKE? 🔴🌰🔥

Related Posts

🚨🏀 Caitlin Clark’s Unexpected Answer to the Angel Reese vs. A’ja Wilson Debate Sparks a Fierce WNBA Discussion — And Her Smirk Says It All 😏🔥 – tammy

The question sounded simple enough, but Caitlin Clark’s reaction immediately changed the atmosphere. During a basketball media discussion, a reporter asked the Indiana Fever star to choose…

🔥😱 Caitlin Clark Caught in a Tense Arena Security Camera Moment — Newly Reviewed Footage Reveals an Unexpected Encounter That Changes Everything – tammy

The basketball arena was nearly empty when Caitlin Clark suddenly stopped walking through a quiet backstage corridor. Just moments earlier, the basketball star had finished a demanding…

🚨💔 Rihanna Confronted Backstage With Unexpected Medical Test Result During New York Performance — Her Emotional Reaction Sparks a Difficult Decision – tammy

The music was still echoing through the arena when Rihanna received a message that abruptly changed the atmosphere backstage. Only minutes earlier, she had been performing before…

🚨💔 Rihanna Shares Heartbreaking Family Update as a Troubling Discovery Raises New Questions About Her Childhood Home – tammy

The room fell silent when Rihanna looked down at the small photograph resting between her hands. For several moments, the global music superstar seemed unable to speak….

🚨💔🎤 EMOTIONAL WWE MOMENT — JOHN CENA IS PORTRAYED FIGHTING BACK TEARS DURING-thuytien

John Cena Breaks Down in Tears During an Emotional Press Conference, Reflecting on Personal Struggles, Family Sacrifices, His WWE Farewell, and the Heartbreaking Journey Behind His Extraordinary…

HEARTBREAKING WWE MOMENT — WRESTLING LEGEND JOHN CENA IS PORTRAYED BREAKING DOWN-thuytien

💔💪 John Cena Breaks Down in Tears During an Emotional Press Conference as a Woman Comforts Him — The Heartbreaking Story Behind His WWE Farewell, Personal Sacrifices,…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *