🚨💙🏈 “THIS COULD CHANGE EVERYTHING!” — BYU’S NOTRE DAME SCHEDULING MYSTERY PUTS BRIAN SANTIAGO AT THE CENTER OF A HIGH-STAKES DECISION!
The Cougars have already proved they can turn a Notre Dame matchup into a national event. Now, reported comments involving university president Shane Reese have raised a bigger question: Should BYU rearrange future football commitments to make room for more meetings with the Fighting Irish?
BYU’s official future schedule confirms a trip to Notre Dame in 2027, Boston College at home in 2028 and away in 2029, and Oregon State in the 2028 Vegas Kickoff Classic. No additional Notre Dame games beyond 2027 have been officially announced.

The latest speculation traces to an October 30 attendee report of Shane Reese’s comments, alongside earlier public expressions of interest from BYU athletic director Brian Santiago. The possibility is credible enough to analyze, but the proposed schedule changes remain unconfirmed.
“THIS COULD CHANGE EVERYTHING!” — BYU’S NOTRE DAME SCHEDULING MYSTERY FORCES BRIAN SANTIAGO TO CONFRONT A MASSIVE DECISION ABOUT THE COUGARS’ FUTURE!
The BYU Cougars have already delivered one of the most significant victories in their recent football history. But the next chapter of their relationship with Notre Dame could involve a battle far more complicated than anything that happens between the sidelines.
Behind the excitement surrounding a possible extension of the football series lies an enormous scheduling question that could influence BYU’s national visibility, future opponents, television opportunities, and long-term competitive strategy.
University president Shane Reese has become central to the discussion following an attendee’s account of remarks suggesting that the Cougars could continue meeting Notre Dame beyond the games already announced.
The possibility has energized supporters who witnessed BYU’s dramatic 28–24 victory over the Fighting Irish on October 17 and immediately began imagining another generation of major encounters between the institutions.
But turning that excitement into additional games will require more than enthusiasm.
BYU already has future agreements involving Boston College, Oregon State, Colorado State, and several other opponents. Those commitments create a complicated calendar for athletic director Brian Santiago and the university’s scheduling decision-makers.
If more Notre Dame matchups become available, BYU may need to consider whether existing games should be moved, renegotiated, or preserved.
Each option carries consequences.
A high-profile series with Notre Dame could strengthen BYU’s national brand and create recurring opportunities for major television exposure. It could also increase competitive risk while introducing scheduling complications and possible contractual costs.
For Cougar Nation, the question is tempting.
Should BYU pursue every realistic opportunity to face the Fighting Irish, even if that means reconsidering agreements already announced?
Or would the program be wiser to protect its existing schedule while waiting for a less disruptive opportunity?
The decision could reveal how BYU intends to position itself within the rapidly evolving college football landscape.
THE REPORTED REMARK THAT STARTED THE MYSTERY
The latest speculation emerged on October 30, when a person attending the BYU Global Real Estate Conference shared an account of university president Shane Reese discussing future games against Notre Dame.
According to the attendee, Reese was asked whether BYU would pursue additional matchups after the success of the October football game.
The attendee attributed a response to Reese suggesting that Notre Dame would appear on BYU’s schedule over the next three years, with further details still being addressed.
That wording immediately attracted attention because the publicly announced agreement currently includes games in 2026 and 2027.
The possibility of additional meetings naturally produced excitement among supporters who want the matchup to become a recurring national event.
But the report requires careful interpretation.
It is an attendee’s account of a conference exchange rather than an official announcement of a completed football contract.
No published scheduling release has established specific additional Notre Dame games beyond 2027.
The distinction matters because a reported discussion can indicate institutional interest without establishing that negotiations have produced a binding agreement.
The story is important precisely because the possibilities are substantial.
But possibilities cannot be treated as confirmed games.
THE ORIGINAL AGREEMENT WAS ALREADY A MAJOR ACCOMPLISHMENT
BYU and Notre Dame officially announced their home-and-home football series on December 22, 2025.
The agreement brought Notre Dame to Provo in 2026 and established a return trip to South Bend for the Cougars in 2027.
For BYU, the announcement represented an important scheduling achievement.
Notre Dame remains one of college football’s most recognizable programs, with a national following and a distinctive independent scheduling model.
Securing a home game against the Fighting Irish provided BYU with an opportunity to showcase LaVell Edwards Stadium before a major national audience.
The agreement also carried historical significance.
The programs have met periodically since 1992, producing memorable games and important moments for both fan bases.
Their connection extends beyond football because both universities possess faith-based institutional identities.
Those characteristics made the partnership especially appealing to administrators.
But its immediate value became clear on the field.
The October 2026 meeting transformed a promising scheduling arrangement into one of the season’s most compelling football stories.
THE OCTOBER VICTORY CHANGED BYU’S POSITION
BYU entered its October 17 showdown against Notre Dame ranked eighth nationally.
The Fighting Irish arrived in Provo ranked second, carrying substantial expectations associated with national championship contention.
The matchup attracted enormous attention.
ESPN College GameDay traveled to campus, while ABC presented the game to a national television audience.
For BYU, the opportunity represented more than hosting a famous opponent.
It offered a chance to demonstrate competitive strength on a major stage.
The Cougars delivered.
Led by quarterback Bear Bachmeier, BYU built an early advantage and entered halftime leading 21–10.
Notre Dame responded during the second half and eventually moved ahead 24–21.
The momentum had changed.
But BYU produced the decisive answer.
Bachmeier connected with Walker Lyons for the touchdown that restored the Cougars’ lead.
The defense then protected the advantage through the final moments.
BYU won 28–24, securing one of its most memorable victories in decades.
That result dramatically increased the appeal of future meetings.
WHY THE 2026 RESULT WAS BIGGER THAN ONE GAME
Defeating Notre Dame provided BYU with a major addition to its competitive résumé.
The Cougars had beaten the nation’s second-ranked team in front of a passionate home crowd and an extensive television audience.
Those circumstances created valuable national exposure.
Recruits could see BYU competing successfully against elite opposition.
Supporters watched their program deliver an extraordinary result on one of college football’s most recognizable stages.
University administrators also received evidence that the matchup could generate substantial interest.
The game combined strong television appeal, an impressive stadium atmosphere, and a finish that remained uncertain until the final moments.
Those characteristics make a football series valuable.
A famous opponent can attract attention.
A compelling contest can sustain that attention.
And a dramatic victory can transform the matchup into a story that supporters anticipate revisiting.
BYU accomplished all three.
The challenge now involves determining whether the university can convert that success into a longer-term scheduling advantage.
THE 2027 REMATCH ALREADY HAS NATIONAL APPEAL
BYU’s scheduled trip to South Bend in 2027 now carries a compelling storyline.
Notre Dame will have an opportunity to respond to the defeat it suffered in Provo.
The Cougars will attempt to demonstrate that their 2026 success can continue away from home.
The matchup also reconnects the programs with an important setting.
BYU last visited Notre Dame Stadium in 2013.
Returning there creates another opportunity to compete in one of college football’s most recognizable venues.
The competitive history strengthens the appeal.
BYU has previously won in South Bend, including its memorable 1994 victory.
Notre Dame has also delivered important wins over the Cougars.
The 2026 result adds a new chapter to that history.
Supporters now have a clear reason to anticipate the next meeting.
But the scheduled 2027 contest remains the only future Notre Dame football game currently confirmed on BYU’s published schedule.
Anything beyond it requires another announcement.
BRIAN SANTIAGO FACES A COMPLICATED STRATEGIC QUESTION
For athletic director Brian Santiago, the possibility of extending the Notre Dame series creates both opportunity and difficulty.
A longer relationship could bring recurring national attention to BYU.
It might also require adjustments to commitments negotiated years earlier.
College football scheduling is not simply a matter of selecting attractive opponents.
Athletic departments must coordinate conference obligations, existing contracts, venue availability, financial considerations, and television arrangements.
Those responsibilities become especially demanding when schedules are established several seasons in advance.
Santiago has already demonstrated that he can navigate complicated negotiations.
The original Notre Dame series emerged through an unusual opening involving other scheduling developments.
Now the challenge could become more demanding.
Instead of filling an unexpected vacancy, BYU might need to create space within a calendar that already contains significant commitments.
That distinction matters.
Finding an available opponent is one challenge.
Changing existing agreements to accommodate a new opponent is another.
THE BOSTON COLLEGE SERIES IS AT THE CENTER OF THE DEBATE
BYU’s future schedule includes a home-and-home series against Boston College.
The Eagles are scheduled to visit Provo in 2028.
BYU is then scheduled to travel to Boston College in 2029.
Those games were publicly announced in September 2024.
The agreement provides BYU with another Power Four opponent and meaningful competition against an ACC program.
It also creates a balanced arrangement involving one home game and one road game.
That structure is important.
Home-and-home contracts allow both institutions to share the benefits of hosting a recognizable opponent.
But they also create reciprocal obligations.
Canceling one game can affect the value of the entire agreement.
If BYU wanted to replace Boston College with Notre Dame, administrators would likely need to address both games and the interests of the Eagles.
That could become a complicated negotiation.
No official announcement indicates that BYU has canceled the Boston College series.
For now, those games remain part of the Cougars’ published schedule.
WHY CANCELING BOSTON COLLEGE IS NOT A SIMPLE DECISION
From a purely promotional perspective, replacing Boston College with Notre Dame might appear attractive.
The Fighting Irish possess a larger national football profile and could generate substantial media attention.
But athletic scheduling cannot be evaluated exclusively through name recognition.
BYU has an existing agreement with Boston College.
Any proposed change would need to account for contractual terms and the other institution’s scheduling needs.
Boston College may already be making preparations based on the announced series.
Its own future calendar could depend on those dates remaining available.
A cancellation might create financial obligations or require alternative arrangements.
The exact contractual consequences have not been publicly established.
Therefore, specific cancellation costs should not be assumed.
But the broader issue is clear.
Changing one agreement can affect several other scheduling decisions.
Santiago would need to consider whether the potential value of additional Notre Dame games justifies the complications created elsewhere.
That calculation could become one of the most important parts of any negotiation.
OREGON STATE COMPLICATES THE 2028 PICTURE
Boston College is not BYU’s only announced opponent in 2028.
The Cougars are also scheduled to face Oregon State in the Vegas Kickoff Classic at Allegiant Stadium.
That neutral-site matchup is part of an existing agreement between the programs.
The 2028 game follows a 2027 meeting in Provo, which has been scheduled for August 28.
Those commitments create additional scheduling considerations.
A neutral-site game carries different commercial and logistical arrangements from an ordinary campus matchup.
It may involve event organizers, venue agreements, and financial structures beyond the two athletic departments.
That makes changes potentially complicated.
BYU cannot simply assume that every future contest can be moved without consequences.
The Oregon State arrangement also provides its own strategic value.
A game in Las Vegas offers a different setting and can attract supporters from multiple regions.
Santiago must evaluate that benefit alongside the potential appeal of Notre Dame.
The decision involves more than choosing which opponent has the bigger name.
THE 2029 SCHEDULE IS ALSO ALREADY TAKING SHAPE
BYU’s published 2029 schedule includes a road game against Boston College and a home game against Colorado State.
Those commitments create a different set of questions.
A road trip to Boston College provides another Power Four matchup, but it also affects travel and home-game balance.
Hosting Colorado State creates an opportunity to renew a historical regional relationship.
The Cougars and Rams previously competed as conference opponents, giving the matchup its own significance.
Additional Notre Dame games could complicate how BYU balances these responsibilities.
An athletic department must consider the overall schedule rather than isolated contests.
A season containing several demanding nonconference opponents may create substantial competitive challenges before conference play develops.
The locations also matter.
Home games provide revenue opportunities and value to supporters.
Road games provide exposure but involve travel and competitive disadvantages.
A schedule with too many demanding trips could create unnecessary difficulties.
Santiago’s challenge is constructing a balanced arrangement that supports both competitive and institutional objectives.
BYU’S FUTURE SCHEDULE EXTENDS WELL BEYOND 2029
The Cougars already have announced football commitments extending into the 2030s.
Northern Illinois, Virginia Tech, Navy, SMU, Michigan State, Coastal Carolina, South Florida, Troy, and Missouri appear among future opponents.
Some of those games were moved from previously announced dates.
Others were established through new agreements.
That history demonstrates how flexible and complicated college football scheduling can become.
BYU has already adjusted commitments in response to changing circumstances.
The university also canceled previously announced series involving Army and Ole Miss during an earlier scheduling revision.
Those examples show that changes are possible.
They do not mean future cancellations are automatically desirable or inexpensive.
Every agreement has its own circumstances.
Administrators must evaluate available options individually.
For the Notre Dame discussion, this historical flexibility provides useful context.
BYU has experience reorganizing future schedules.
But a potential extension with the Fighting Irish would still require careful negotiation.
THE BIG 12’S NONCONFERENCE REQUIREMENTS MATTER
BYU’s membership in the Big 12 creates obligations that influence future scheduling.
Conference games occupy a substantial portion of the regular season.
The league has also required programs to schedule appropriate Power Four nonconference competition.
That structure makes opponents such as Notre Dame and Boston College strategically important.
Both can help BYU meet competitive scheduling expectations.
But the Cougars cannot simply add unlimited games.
College football seasons contain a fixed number of regular-season contests.
Every additional nonconference opponent must fit around conference responsibilities and existing commitments.
That creates tradeoffs.
Scheduling Notre Dame could strengthen the team’s national profile.
But it might require replacing another valuable opponent.
BYU must also consider the difficulty of the entire schedule.
A high-profile matchup can enhance a postseason résumé.
It can also introduce additional risk.
The correct decision depends on how the pieces fit together.
DOES NOTRE DAME OFFER MORE VALUE THAN BOSTON COLLEGE?
The central strategic comparison involves the potential benefits of different opponents.
Notre Dame offers extraordinary brand recognition and a nationally followed football tradition.
Boston College provides another Power Four opponent and a recognizable ACC matchup.
Both can create meaningful competition.
But their national visibility differs.
A BYU–Notre Dame game is more likely to attract widespread attention because of the programs’ established histories and recent dramatic meeting.
That exposure could support recruiting and national branding.
However, the football difficulty also matters.
Notre Dame regularly pursues national championship contention and recruits at a high level.
Facing the Fighting Irish could provide a major opportunity.
It could also increase the likelihood of a difficult result.
Boston College presents its own competitive challenges, but the strategic considerations may differ.
BYU must determine how much additional exposure is worth when balanced against contractual obligations and competitive risk.
There is no simple answer based solely on opponent reputation.
A NOTRE DAME SERIES COULD CREATE A RECRUITING ADVANTAGE
Recruiting is one of the most compelling arguments for pursuing more Notre Dame games.
High-profile matchups create opportunities for young athletes to see a program competing on a major stage.
BYU’s 2026 victory provided an extraordinary example.
The Cougars defeated the nation’s second-ranked team before an enthusiastic home crowd and national television audience.
That performance can become a useful recruiting story.
Coaches can demonstrate that players who choose BYU may participate in nationally significant games.
They can also point toward the program’s ability to compete successfully against prestigious opponents.
Additional Notre Dame matchups could create more opportunities for similar exposure.
But recruiting benefits should not be overstated.
Prospects consider coaching relationships, player development, academics, financial opportunities, and individual fit.
One opponent does not determine recruiting success.
Still, recurring games against Notre Dame could strengthen the overall presentation of BYU football.
That potential deserves serious consideration.
NATIONAL TELEVISION EXPOSURE COULD BECOME A MAJOR BENEFIT
A recurring BYU–Notre Dame matchup could create attractive opportunities for television networks.
Both institutions possess nationally engaged fan bases.
Their football histories and distinctive identities provide compelling promotional material.
The 2026 game demonstrated the matchup’s ability to generate substantial national attention.
ESPN College GameDay traveled to Provo.
ABC televised the contest.
The game then delivered a dramatic finish worthy of its prominent presentation.
Those elements create a valuable example for future negotiations.
Broadcasters want games capable of attracting attention beyond local markets.
BYU and Notre Dame offer that possibility.
However, additional television arrangements have not been announced.
The value of future games would depend on schedules, broadcast rights, and competitive circumstances.
No specific revenue increase should be assumed without contractual information.
The strategic potential is clear.
The financial outcome remains uncertain.
LA VELL EDWARDS STADIUM COULD BENEFIT ENORMOUSLY
Another Notre Dame visit to Provo could provide substantial value to BYU’s home-game experience.
LaVell Edwards Stadium demonstrated its ability to host a major national event during the 2026 matchup.
The crowd created a memorable atmosphere.
The Cougars delivered a historic victory.
And the program received extensive national exposure.
Repeating that experience could benefit supporters and strengthen the stadium’s reputation as a destination for important games.
Home contests also create opportunities for university events, alumni engagement, and local economic activity.
Those benefits can extend beyond the football field.
But BYU must ensure that any proposed series includes a favorable balance of home and road games.
A collection of prestigious road matchups would not provide the same home-stadium advantages.
The structure of the agreement matters.
Santiago should evaluate not only the opponent but also the locations and timing of future contests.
THE SOUTH BEND EXPERIENCE HAS ITS OWN VALUE
Notre Dame Stadium provides a different kind of opportunity.
For visiting players, competing there carries historical significance.
BYU’s scheduled 2027 trip will offer another chance to perform on that stage.
The Cougars last played in South Bend in 2013.
Their previous road victory against Notre Dame came in 1994.
Those historical moments remain part of BYU’s football identity.
Additional trips could create opportunities for new generations of players to establish their own memories.
Road victories against prominent opponents can strengthen national reputations.
They also demonstrate the ability to compete in demanding environments.
But road games introduce challenges involving travel, crowd conditions, and preparation.
BYU must balance the prestige of those opportunities against the competitive benefits of hosting games.
A longer series should ideally provide meaningful value at both stadiums.
That balance would help make the relationship sustainable.
THE FAITH-BASED CONNECTION GIVES THE RELATIONSHIP DEPTH
BYU and Notre Dame share a distinctive position within college athletics.
Both are private universities with religious traditions that influence their institutional identities.
BYU is associated with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Notre Dame is a Catholic university.
Those traditions differ, but both institutions incorporate faith into their broader educational missions.
Their administrators have recognized that connection as an important part of the relationship.
The partnership therefore carries meaning extending beyond football competition.
It creates opportunities for the universities to showcase their identities while engaging in respected athletic competition.
That broader connection may encourage continued cooperation.
Santiago has discussed the value of building a relationship involving multiple sports.
Such cooperation could provide benefits even if football scheduling becomes difficult.
The institutions do not need identical traditions to recognize shared values.
Their differences can coexist with mutual respect.
That distinction helps make the matchup distinctive.
SHANE REESE’S ROLE MAKES THE SPECULATION MORE INTERESTING
The reported remarks attributed to university president Shane Reese attract attention because they involve leadership beyond the athletic department.
University presidents consider broader institutional priorities.
Those priorities can include public visibility, relationships with other universities, and opportunities connecting academics and athletics.
A long-term Notre Dame partnership could support several of those objectives.
That possibility may help explain why the relationship emerged during a conference discussion outside an ordinary football news event.
However, the reported wording remains unverified through an official transcript.
It also does not establish the terms of a completed agreement.
The distinction should shape the conversation.
Reese may see substantial value in continued cooperation.
Santiago may be interested in additional football games.
But actual scheduling commitments require coordination and formal confirmation.
The university president’s involvement makes the possibility noteworthy.
It does not eliminate the logistical obstacles.
SANTIAGO HAS ALREADY DEMONSTRATED NEGOTIATING FLEXIBILITY
The original BYU–Notre Dame series emerged from an unusual sequence of scheduling developments.
BYU needed a new prominent nonconference opponent after its planned California series became unworkable.
Notre Dame was also adjusting its schedule amid uncertainty involving traditional opponents.
Those circumstances created an unexpected opening.
Santiago developed a relationship with Notre Dame athletic director Pete Bevacqua and helped transform that opportunity into the announced home-and-home series.
The agreement required cooperation involving existing schedules and institutional relationships.
That accomplishment matters because it demonstrates the importance of communication.
College football scheduling can become complicated quickly.
An athletic director who maintains productive relationships may identify opportunities unavailable through ordinary planning.
The Notre Dame agreement provided a strong example.
Now Santiago could face another challenge.
Extending the relationship might require more deliberate restructuring rather than taking advantage of a convenient vacancy.
That would test his negotiating approach in a different way.
THE REAL COST OF CANCELING GAMES IS UNKNOWN
One reason the Notre Dame speculation requires caution involves potential financial consequences.
Future football contracts may include provisions governing cancellation, rescheduling, or changes in venue.
The terms can vary substantially between agreements.
BYU’s specific potential costs associated with changing the Boston College series have not been established publicly in the information available.
Therefore, claiming that the university would owe a particular amount would be unsupported.
The broader financial calculation remains important.
A Notre Dame game could generate substantial attention and commercial opportunities.
But replacing an existing opponent might introduce costs.
Those expenses could reduce the net value of the new agreement.
Santiago would need to compare potential benefits with actual contractual obligations.
He would also need to consider the value of preserving relationships with other institutions.
A successful scheduling strategy should create opportunities without unnecessarily damaging future cooperation.
Financial details matter as much as football excitement.
RESCHEDULING COULD BE MORE ATTRACTIVE THAN CANCELING
One possible strategy would involve moving existing games rather than abandoning them.
BYU has previously rescheduled several future football commitments.
That experience demonstrates that changes can sometimes be negotiated.
A Boston College matchup might theoretically be moved to another season if both institutions agreed and their calendars allowed it.
Such an arrangement could preserve the relationship while creating room for Notre Dame.
But that outcome cannot be assumed.
Boston College would need compatible dates.
BYU would need available openings.
Any additional parties involved in existing arrangements might also require consideration.
The process could become complicated.
Still, rescheduling provides an alternative to an immediate choice between Notre Dame and Boston College.
It offers the possibility of maintaining both relationships over a longer period.
Whether that option is realistic depends on negotiations that have not been publicly detailed.
The possibility is worth exploring.
It is not a confirmed solution.
COULD BYU WAIT UNTIL A LATER SEASON?
Another strategy would involve extending the Notre Dame relationship without forcing changes to the immediate schedule.
The universities could consider future openings beyond the busiest years.
That approach might reduce the need to renegotiate existing agreements.
It could also allow both athletic departments more time to establish a balanced home-and-home arrangement.
However, waiting introduces a different challenge.
Future schedules may already contain significant commitments.
Notre Dame’s independent structure includes numerous longstanding opponents and national matchups.
BYU’s Big 12 obligations will continue shaping its calendar.
A later agreement might therefore require negotiations regardless of the year selected.
Still, flexibility over timing could improve the chances of finding a workable solution.
A meaningful rivalry does not necessarily require annual meetings.
Games separated by several seasons can still maintain strong interest if the programs continue producing competitive matchups.
The key is preserving the relationship.
NOTRE DAME HAS ITS OWN SCHEDULING CHALLENGES
The Fighting Irish operate under a distinctive football scheduling structure.
Their independence creates opportunities to face opponents from multiple conferences.
But it also requires managing numerous longstanding commitments.
Notre Dame maintains relationships with ACC opponents and other nationally recognized programs.
Those obligations occupy substantial portions of future schedules.
A new BYU series must fit within that framework.
The Fighting Irish cannot simply select additional dates without considering their existing agreements.
That means the scheduling challenge extends beyond Provo.
Bevacqua must also determine whether Notre Dame can accommodate more games against BYU.
The 2026–2027 agreement succeeded because the calendars aligned.
Further expansion could require additional flexibility.
Both athletic departments would need to identify terms that benefit their institutions.
A successful partnership depends on mutual opportunity.
BYU cannot create the series alone.
THE 2028 NOTRE DAME CALENDAR IS ALREADY CROWDED
Notre Dame’s future schedule includes several recognizable opponents during 2028.
The Fighting Irish have announced games involving Texas, Arkansas, Purdue, Clemson, Stanford, Auburn, Virginia Tech, Boston College, Miami, and Pittsburgh.
Those commitments demonstrate the complexity of adding another major matchup.
A future BYU game could require available space or changes elsewhere.
The same applies to 2029, when Notre Dame already has important opponents scheduled.
That reality makes any claim about an imminent annual series premature.
The universities must first establish workable dates.
The challenge involves more than identifying a desirable opponent.
It requires fitting the matchup into a broader competitive structure.
For BYU supporters, the crowded Notre Dame calendar may be frustrating.
But it also highlights why a productive administrative relationship matters.
Santiago and Bevacqua need flexibility if the partnership is to expand.
Their previous cooperation provides a useful foundation.
WHY A HIGH-RISK SCHEDULE COULD HELP BYU
There is a strong argument for embracing demanding nonconference opponents.
College football’s most compelling programs frequently demonstrate their quality through important games against recognizable competition.
BYU’s victory over Notre Dame provided exactly that kind of opportunity.
A strong result against an elite opponent can influence national perception and postseason conversations.
It can also strengthen confidence within the program.
Players learn how to perform under pressure.
Coaches gain experience preparing for demanding opponents.
Supporters witness games with substantial stakes.
Those benefits can support long-term development.
A recurring Notre Dame matchup could provide BYU with more of those opportunities.
However, the advantages depend on competitive performance.
Scheduling a famous opponent creates a chance.
It does not guarantee a positive result.
The Cougars must be prepared to accept that uncertainty.
Programs pursuing national relevance often face difficult strategic choices.
BYU may decide that the potential rewards justify the challenge.
THE SAME STRATEGY COULD CREATE UNNECESSARY RISK
The counterargument is equally important.
BYU already faces demanding conference competition in the Big 12.
Adding recurring games against Notre Dame could increase the difficulty of an already challenging schedule.
A nonconference defeat might complicate postseason ambitions.
Multiple demanding matchups could also increase physical and preparation burdens.
Those risks matter in a playoff environment where every result can influence national evaluation.
The Cougars must consider competitive balance.
A schedule filled with recognizable opponents may attract attention.
But a successful season also depends on maintaining consistency across all games.
An athletic department should not pursue prestige without evaluating the broader consequences.
The goal is constructing a schedule that supports national ambition.
That may involve carefully selecting high-profile opponents rather than maximizing their number.
For Santiago, the challenge is identifying the right balance.
Exposure matters.
Winning matters too.
Neither objective should be considered in isolation.
THE COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF CHANGES THE CALCULATION
The expanded playoff era has influenced how programs evaluate schedules.
A strong nonconference victory can enhance a team’s résumé.
But an additional loss can create complications, depending on the broader season and selection criteria.
BYU’s Notre Dame victory demonstrated the upside.
The Cougars defeated an elite opponent and strengthened their national standing.
That result provided a meaningful achievement beyond ordinary conference competition.
A recurring series would create more opportunities for similar victories.
However, it would also create more opportunities for difficult defeats.
The selection committee evaluates teams through a broader body of work.
No single nonconference game guarantees a particular postseason outcome.
For BYU, the strategic decision must consider both potential benefits and risks.
A strong schedule can create valuable opportunities.
It does not eliminate the importance of winning.
The program must evaluate how additional Notre Dame games would fit within its overall championship ambitions.
KALANI SITAKE WOULD WELCOME THE COMPETITION
BYU head coach Kalani Sitake has expressed enthusiasm for the possibility of continuing the Notre Dame series.
His interest is understandable.
The 2026 victory provided one of the most memorable accomplishments of his coaching tenure.
The game also demonstrated BYU’s ability to compete against an elite opponent.
For Sitake, additional matchups could create opportunities to reinforce the program’s competitive identity.
They would also provide important experiences for his players.
Facing Notre Dame requires detailed preparation and the ability to respond under pressure.
Those challenges can support team development.
But Sitake must also manage the demands of the Big 12 schedule.
He cannot focus exclusively on one prestigious opponent.
The overall season remains the priority.
A successful scheduling strategy should help the program compete for conference and national success.
Sitake’s enthusiasm provides another reason the relationship may continue.
The final decision must balance that enthusiasm with broader institutional considerations.
THE NOTRE DAME SERIES IS ALREADY PRODUCING A STORYLINE
One reason the matchup has become so appealing is the immediate competitive history created by the 2026 result.
BYU defeated the second-ranked Fighting Irish.
Notre Dame will have an opportunity to respond in South Bend.
That naturally creates anticipation.
Supporters remember the decisive touchdown to Walker Lyons.
They remember Bachmeier’s versatility.
They remember Notre Dame’s late comeback attempt.
Those moments provide emotional connections that can sustain interest between games.
A longer series could create additional chapters.
Players would have opportunities to respond to previous defeats.
Coaches could adjust strategies based on earlier meetings.
Fan bases would develop stronger familiarity.
Those elements contribute to meaningful rivalries.
But the relationship must be built through actual competition.
Scheduling announcements alone cannot guarantee memorable games.
The 2026 matchup delivered an extraordinary foundation.
The 2027 rematch will provide the next confirmed opportunity.
HISTORICAL MEETINGS GIVE THE SERIES DEPTH
BYU and Notre Dame have competed periodically since 1992.
The series includes important victories for both programs.
BYU’s 1994 win in South Bend remains a significant historical accomplishment.
The Cougars also defeated Notre Dame in Provo during the 2004 season.
The Fighting Irish won their later meeting in South Bend in 2013.
They also defeated BYU during the 2022 Shamrock Series matchup in Las Vegas.
Those games provide historical context for the modern renewal.
The 2026 victory added another dramatic chapter.
A longer relationship could connect different generations of supporters.
Former players could recognize familiar opponents.
Current athletes could contribute new memories.
Younger fans might begin viewing the matchup as a recurring feature of BYU football.
That continuity can create lasting interest.
The programs already possess a meaningful history.
Additional games could deepen it.
A PERMANENT RIVALRY WOULD REQUIRE MUTUAL COMMITMENT
The idea of an annual BYU–Notre Dame matchup is appealing to many supporters.
Both programs possess distinctive identities and nationally followed football traditions.
Their recent game demonstrated that the matchup can generate major attention.
But a permanent rivalry would require significant scheduling commitments.
Notre Dame maintains a complicated independent schedule.
BYU must meet Big 12 obligations.
Both institutions have existing future opponents.
Those factors make an annual arrangement challenging.
A more realistic possibility might involve additional home-and-home agreements spread across several years.
That approach could preserve the relationship without requiring annual games.
However, even that structure remains speculative until confirmed.
The reported Reese comments do not establish a permanent rivalry.
They suggest a possible continuation.
That is an important distinction.
The universities may eventually develop a recurring tradition.
For now, the confirmed schedule provides only the next meeting in 2027.
THE IMPACT ON OTHER COLLEGE PROGRAMS MATTERS
Scheduling decisions affect more than the institutions negotiating a new series.
Boston College, Oregon State, Colorado State, and other opponents have their own competitive and financial considerations.
A change involving BYU could require those schools to adjust their schedules.
That might create opportunities.
It might also introduce difficulties.
For example, Boston College could need to identify another Power Four opponent if an existing game were canceled.
Oregon State’s neutral-site arrangements involve additional planning considerations.
Colorado State’s relationship with BYU includes historical significance and previously announced dates.
Those institutions should not be treated as disposable pieces of a scheduling puzzle.
Their agreements deserve consideration.
A responsible athletic department should evaluate the consequences of changes throughout the system.
BYU can pursue national opportunities while maintaining professional relationships with other programs.
That balance matters for future negotiations.
A reputation for cooperation can be valuable.
SANTIAGO MUST PROTECT BYU’S LONG-TERM FLEXIBILITY
A major scheduling decision should consider more than the next two seasons.
BYU’s competitive environment will continue changing.
Conference structures, television arrangements, and playoff systems may evolve.
An athletic department benefits from maintaining some flexibility.
Locking too many future dates into difficult opponents could create challenges if circumstances change.
However, securing recognizable opponents can also provide stability.
A successful Notre Dame series might offer predictable national exposure for several seasons.
The decision therefore involves competing forms of flexibility.
One approach preserves open opportunities.
Another establishes valuable commitments with a major football brand.
Santiago must determine which structure best supports BYU’s long-term goals.
The answer may involve limited extensions rather than an enormous permanent agreement.
A carefully negotiated series could provide benefits while preserving room for other opportunities.
That possibility deserves serious consideration.
THE UNIVERSITY’S BROADER BRAND IS PART OF THE DISCUSSION
BYU’s national identity extends beyond football.
The university has distinctive academic, religious, and cultural traditions.
High-profile athletic events can provide opportunities to introduce those characteristics to broader audiences.
The Notre Dame series is especially relevant because both institutions recognize faith as part of their missions.
That shared dimension provides a foundation for cooperation beyond competition.
A major football game can bring administrators, alumni, students, and supporters together.
It can also create conversations about institutional values.
Those benefits are difficult to measure through a scoreboard alone.
However, they remain strategically important.
University leadership may view the partnership through a broader lens than a single athletic department.
The reported Reese comments attract attention partly because of that perspective.
A continued relationship could support institutional visibility.
But the exact terms would still need to be established.
COULD OTHER SPORTS BECOME PART OF THE PARTNERSHIP?
Santiago has previously discussed the possibility of broader athletic cooperation with Notre Dame.
That could include matchups in sports beyond football.
Such arrangements might create opportunities without requiring major changes to the football schedule.
Basketball and other sports operate under different scheduling structures.
Those differences can provide additional flexibility.
A broader partnership might help sustain institutional connections while football administrators work through calendar challenges.
However, no unannounced contests should be treated as confirmed.
The significance lies in the universities’ expressed interest in cooperation.
Football remains the most visible opportunity because of its national following and commercial importance.
But other sports could contribute to a more lasting relationship.
That perspective broadens the conversation.
The schools may be considering more than a simple extension of two football games.
Their long-term relationship could develop through multiple athletic opportunities.
THE WORD SECRETIVE SHOULD NOT BE CONFUSED WITH SUSPICIOUS
The lack of an official announcement has naturally encouraged speculation about private negotiations.
But confidential scheduling discussions are common in college athletics.
Athletic departments frequently explore potential games before contracts are finalized.
Those conversations may involve dates, venues, financial terms, and existing obligations.
Public announcements usually occur after the necessary arrangements are complete.
The absence of immediate details does not establish wrongdoing or deliberate concealment.
It may simply reflect an unfinished process.
The reported Reese comments have increased interest because they suggest the possibility of continued cooperation.
But there is no evidence establishing that the university has completed a secret agreement while intentionally misleading supporters.
The more useful question concerns what the athletic departments are attempting to arrange.
That is a legitimate subject for analysis.
Speculation should remain connected to available facts.
The potential scheduling consequences are substantial enough without unsupported allegations.
WHY COUGARBOARD’S REPORT SHOULD BE READ CAREFULLY
The October 30 account originated with a person who said they attended the BYU Global Real Estate Conference.
The attendee reported hearing Reese discuss future Notre Dame games.
That account provides a specific reason for the latest speculation.
But it is not the same as a verified recording or official university transcript.
The exact wording and context could influence interpretation.
For example, a reference to the next three years might not necessarily mean three newly contracted football seasons beyond the current agreement.
The attendee’s account suggested additional details were still being considered.
That reinforces the importance of avoiding premature conclusions.
Supporters can reasonably discuss the possibilities.
Journalistic analysis can examine the scheduling implications.
But the next definitive development must come through formal confirmation.
The report is a lead worth following.
It is not a completed schedule.
THE FINANCIAL BENEFITS COULD BE SIGNIFICANT BUT ARE NOT GUARANTEED
More games against Notre Dame could create opportunities for stronger attendance demand, television exposure, sponsorship attention, and alumni engagement.
Those possibilities make the partnership attractive.
However, no verified projections establish the exact financial benefit of additional games.
Home and road locations would influence revenue.
Broadcast rights would also matter.
A neutral-site arrangement could create a different financial structure.
Potential costs associated with changing existing contracts must be considered.
The net value of an agreement therefore depends on details that have not been announced.
It would be premature to claim that replacing Boston College automatically guarantees a particular financial gain.
The broader commercial appeal of Notre Dame is evident.
The actual financial calculation requires contract information.
For Santiago, that calculation should remain central to any decision.
A compelling matchup must also make practical sense for the institution.
THE COMPETITIVE BENEFITS DEPEND ON WINNING
BYU’s 2026 victory over Notre Dame provided extraordinary value because the Cougars delivered a meaningful result.
The program did not simply participate in a nationally televised game.
It defeated a highly ranked opponent.
That outcome strengthened its competitive reputation.
But future games could unfold differently.
Notre Dame possesses substantial talent and resources.
A recurring series would expose BYU to demanding competition.
That challenge could help the Cougars develop.
It could also produce difficult defeats.
The strategic value therefore depends partly on BYU’s ability to remain competitive.
High-profile exposure is most beneficial when accompanied by strong performances.
Sitake’s team demonstrated that capacity in 2026.
Maintaining it will require recruiting, development, and consistent preparation.
A longer agreement could create more opportunities.
It cannot guarantee their outcomes.
THE BIG 12 CHAMPIONSHIP RACE MUST REMAIN THE PRIORITY
BYU’s future ambitions depend heavily on success within the Big 12.
Conference victories influence championship qualification and postseason opportunities.
Those games cannot be treated as secondary to prestigious nonconference matchups.
A recurring Notre Dame series could enhance BYU’s national profile.
But the Cougars must also remain prepared for demanding conference opponents.
A difficult nonconference schedule can affect physical preparation and competitive momentum.
Those consequences deserve consideration.
Santiago and Sitake should evaluate the entire season when considering new commitments.
The objective is not creating the most impressive collection of opponent names.
It is building a schedule that supports national and conference championship ambitions.
Those goals can align.
They can also create tension.
A carefully structured Notre Dame relationship could provide value without undermining the broader schedule.
That should be the central strategic aim.
A FLEXIBLE EXTENSION MAY BE THE STRONGEST OPTION
One potential approach would involve negotiating additional Notre Dame games while preserving as many existing commitments as possible.
That could require future dates outside the busiest scheduling years.
It might also involve rescheduling rather than canceling other agreements.
A limited extension could provide meaningful national exposure without creating excessive contractual disruption.
Such an approach would preserve the relationship while allowing administrators to evaluate how future college football structures develop.
But its feasibility remains uncertain.
Both universities would need compatible dates.
Other athletic departments might need to cooperate.
The financial terms would also matter.
No public announcement establishes that this approach is currently being negotiated.
It is simply one strategic possibility.
The appeal lies in balancing ambition with flexibility.
BYU could continue pursuing a nationally significant matchup without assuming that every existing opponent must be replaced.
COUGAR NATION’S ENTHUSIASM IS UNDERSTANDABLE
Supporters witnessed an extraordinary game against Notre Dame in October.
The Cougars defeated the nation’s second-ranked team and created a memorable atmosphere in Provo.
Naturally, fans want more.
The matchup offers recognizable traditions, national attention, and meaningful competition.
It also creates opportunities to strengthen BYU’s standing beyond the Big 12.
That enthusiasm is legitimate.
But supporters should recognize that athletic departments must balance competing responsibilities.
A desired game may not fit the existing schedule.
A contract change may create costs.
An additional elite opponent may increase competitive risk.
Those considerations do not diminish the appeal of Notre Dame.
They explain why the decision requires careful analysis.
BYU has already demonstrated that the partnership can succeed.
The next question is whether additional agreements can be arranged without creating disproportionate problems elsewhere.
That is the real challenge.
THE 2027 GAME COULD INFLUENCE FUTURE NEGOTIATIONS
The scheduled return matchup in South Bend may provide another opportunity to demonstrate the series’ value.
The Fighting Irish will be motivated to respond to their 2026 defeat.
BYU will seek another important victory against a nationally recognized opponent.
The result could influence future perception of the rivalry.
A second competitive game would reinforce the idea that these programs create compelling matchups.
A strong television audience and meaningful atmosphere could also strengthen the commercial case for additional meetings.
However, athletic departments do not necessarily need to wait until after the 2027 game to negotiate future schedules.
Agreements are often arranged years in advance.
The relationship may already be part of ongoing conversations.
The confirmed rematch provides an important foundation regardless.
It guarantees another nationally interesting chapter.
Anything beyond that remains subject to announcement.
THERE IS NO NEED TO RUSH INTO AN EXPENSIVE DECISION
The excitement surrounding Notre Dame should not pressure BYU into accepting an unfavorable agreement.
The university has already secured the 2027 matchup.
It has existing future opponents.
And its football program remains nationally relevant following the October victory.
Those advantages provide negotiating strength.
Santiago does not need to abandon established commitments merely because supporters want additional games immediately.
The athletic department should evaluate timing, locations, costs, and competitive balance.
If the right opportunity becomes available, an extension could be valuable.
If the available terms create excessive complications, waiting may be reasonable.
The objective should be building a sustainable relationship.
A rushed agreement might generate short-term excitement while creating long-term scheduling problems.
BYU has already shown that it can capitalize on a major opportunity.
The next step should reflect the same attention to detail.
THE NATIONAL LANDSCAPE IS CHANGING QUICKLY
College football continues evolving through conference realignment, expanded postseason opportunities, and increasingly complex television arrangements.
Those developments influence how schools schedule future opponents.
Games agreed upon several years earlier may become difficult to accommodate when conference structures change.
BYU has already experienced that challenge.
Its original California arrangement became unworkable after ACC scheduling developments.
The Notre Dame opportunity emerged partly because of those changes.
That history demonstrates why athletic departments need flexibility.
A future Notre Dame extension could provide valuable stability.
But it could also create obligations that become complicated if the sport changes again.
Santiago must account for that uncertainty.
Long-term agreements should be structured to withstand reasonable scheduling adjustments.
The current environment rewards programs capable of adapting.
BYU’s recent experience provides evidence of that importance.
THE DECISION WILL HELP DEFINE SANTIAGO’S APPROACH
Santiago’s role involves balancing immediate football opportunities with the university’s longer-term interests.
His success in arranging the initial Notre Dame series provided a major accomplishment.
Now the possibility of additional meetings creates a different challenge.
The athletic director must determine how aggressively to pursue high-profile opponents.
He must also protect relationships with institutions already on BYU’s schedule.
Those responsibilities can conflict.
A prominent new opportunity may appear attractive while creating difficulties elsewhere.
Effective leadership requires evaluating the complete picture.
The most successful outcome would provide meaningful exposure without imposing unnecessary costs or competitive disadvantages.
That may require creative negotiations.
It may also require patience.
Santiago’s decisions could influence how BYU structures nonconference schedules for years.
The Notre Dame discussion therefore represents more than one potential contract.
It is a test of strategic priorities.
THE UNIVERSITY SHOULD THINK BEYOND ONE OPPONENT
Notre Dame provides exceptional national appeal, but BYU’s scheduling strategy should not depend exclusively on one program.
The Cougars benefit from maintaining relationships with opponents across different conferences and regions.
Those connections create flexibility and a variety of competitive opportunities.
Boston College offers an ACC matchup.
Oregon State provides another familiar regional opponent with a neutral-site opportunity.
Colorado State connects BYU with part of its conference history.
Other future games offer different forms of exposure.
That diversity has value.
A strong scheduling portfolio can help BYU maintain national relevance while adapting to changing circumstances.
The Notre Dame relationship could become its most visible component.
But it should not automatically replace every other opportunity.
The challenge is integrating a prestigious opponent into a sustainable overall strategy.
That approach may provide greater long-term value than concentrating too heavily on a single series.
THE BEST OUTCOME WOULD BALANCE PRESTIGE AND RESPONSIBILITY
The central decision does not need to be framed as choosing between ambition and caution.
BYU can pursue major opponents while respecting existing commitments.
It can seek national attention without ignoring competitive balance.
And it can explore creative scheduling options without assuming that cancellation is the only solution.
That balance should guide any potential Notre Dame extension.
The university already has a valuable relationship with the Fighting Irish.
Its leaders have expressed interest in continued cooperation.
The 2026 victory demonstrated the matchup’s potential.
Those achievements provide a strong foundation.
Now the practical details must determine what happens next.
An attractive agreement should create benefits for both universities.
It should also account for the obligations already established.
That is the difference between an exciting idea and a sustainable strategic decision.
THE FINAL VERDICT: BYU SHOULD PURSUE NOTRE DAME, BUT NOT AT ANY COST
The possibility of extending BYU’s football relationship with Notre Dame has created one of the most interesting scheduling debates surrounding the Cougars.
A reported October 30 comment attributed to university president Shane Reese suggested that additional meetings may be under discussion.
That account generated excitement because the officially confirmed agreement currently extends only through the 2027 game in South Bend.
BYU has already demonstrated the enormous value of the matchup.
On October 17, the Cougars defeated the second-ranked Fighting Irish 28–24 in a dramatic contest at LaVell Edwards Stadium.
The victory attracted national attention and strengthened the program’s competitive reputation.
Bear Bachmeier delivered an extraordinary performance.
Walker Lyons caught the decisive touchdown.
The defense protected the lead through the final moments.
The result created an unforgettable chapter in the universities’ shared football history.
Additional games could provide similar opportunities.
They might strengthen BYU’s recruiting presentation, national television exposure, and ability to showcase its program against elite competition.
They could also create recurring excitement for supporters in Provo and South Bend.
But the schedule already contains important commitments.
Boston College is scheduled to visit BYU in 2028.
The Cougars are scheduled to travel to Boston College in 2029.
Oregon State is also on the calendar, including the 2028 Vegas Kickoff Classic.
Colorado State and other opponents occupy additional future dates.
Those agreements cannot be dismissed simply because Notre Dame offers greater national recognition.
Changes could require negotiation, rescheduling, or financial considerations.
The exact contractual consequences remain unknown.
That uncertainty should influence the decision.
Brian Santiago must compare the potential benefits of additional Notre Dame games with the costs and obligations associated with modifying the existing schedule.
He must also consider the competitive difficulty of BYU’s future seasons.
The Cougars already compete within a demanding Big 12 environment.
Adding another elite opponent creates opportunity and risk.
A victory could strengthen the program’s national profile.
A defeat could complicate postseason ambitions.
Neither outcome is guaranteed.
That is why a balanced strategy matters.
BYU should continue exploring ways to extend the Notre Dame relationship.
The institutions share distinctive identities and have already established a productive administrative partnership.
The original agreement demonstrates that cooperation is possible.
The 2026 game proves that the matchup can generate extraordinary interest.
The scheduled 2027 rematch provides another opportunity to build the rivalry.
Those are strong reasons to keep discussing future games.
But a longer relationship should be pursued through terms that protect BYU’s broader interests.
Rescheduling existing opponents may be worth considering if all parties can reach acceptable arrangements.
Later dates may provide another option.
A limited extension could create substantial value without requiring a permanent annual commitment.
The right structure remains uncertain.
No additional football games beyond 2027 have been officially confirmed.
The reported Reese comments should not be treated as proof of a completed multiyear agreement.
The precise dates, locations, and terms remain unknown.
That distinction is essential.
The excitement is legitimate.
The speculation is understandable.
The strategic possibilities are substantial.
But the next important development must come through a formal announcement.
For Cougar Nation, the 2026 Notre Dame victory will remain meaningful regardless of what happens next.
BYU proved it could host a major national event and defeat a highly ranked opponent.
The 2027 rematch will provide another chapter.
Additional games could help transform the relationship into a lasting rivalry.
But the athletic department should ensure that ambition does not become unnecessary disruption.
BYU has every reason to pursue more football games against Notre Dame. The matchup offers enormous opportunities for national visibility, recruiting, and memorable competition.
However, the university should not automatically sacrifice existing commitments without understanding the contractual, financial, and competitive consequences.
Brian Santiago’s challenge is to negotiate an arrangement that strengthens BYU’s future without creating avoidable problems elsewhere on the schedule.
The confirmed Notre Dame series already delivered an extraordinary victory in Provo and guarantees another major matchup in South Bend in 2027.
A longer partnership could become one of BYU’s most valuable scheduling assets, but its success will depend on careful planning rather than speculation.
The strongest strategy is clear: keep pursuing Notre Dame, preserve flexibility, honor existing obligations wherever practical, and accept changes only when the long-term benefits justify them.
BYU has already proved that it belongs on college football’s biggest stages. The next scheduling decision should help keep the Cougars there for years to come.